欧洲联盟法经典案例课程（双语））Case Study on European Union Law教学大纲兰花 编写Dr. LAN HuaLecturer, Faculty of International Law, CUPL
欧洲联盟法经典案例课程（双语)） Case Study on European Union Law 教学大纲 兰花 编写 Dr. LAN Hua Lecturer, Faculty of International Law, CUPL
欧洲联盟法经典案例课程（双语）目录前言22ChapterOneIntroductionI.General introductionof EuropeanCommunitiesII.the Law of theEuropean Union1II.Basic Institutions of EUIV.LisbonTreatyandEuropeanpolicies4Chapter Two IRAC---case analysis model.6L案例的基本结构（BasicStructureofCtOpinions-6II. Content of the case analysis....6IIl.Review and assess the case law....6IV.Writing the Case Brief.......ChapterThreePrincipleof directeffect:Constitutional AdministrativeAspectsofEULaw.*+..7SectionI.Principle of direct effect....1Case No.1Van Gend en Loos case:creation of direct effectprincipleI.Significance...II.Basic information of the case...7III. Holding...8IV.Analysis-- Principle of Direct Effect.8Section2LaterdevelopmentofprincipleofdirecteffectICaseNo.2Defrenne case:horizontal direct effectII. Case No.3Fratelli Variola Case: Regulations and Direct EffectCCIII.CaseNo.3FranzGradCase:DecisionsandDirectEffectIV. Related Legal Issues..ChapterFourPrinciple of Primacy:ConstitutionalAdministrativeAspectsof EULaw11Section 1 Principle of Primacy...11I Basic information.1111II. Holding...12II. Related Legal Issues...IV.ThePrincipleof Supremacy12Section2LaterdevelopmentofprincipleofPrimacy.12I CaseNo.2 Simmenthal case..II. Cassis de Dijon, Case 120/7812II.LaterdevelopmentofprincipleofPrimacy1214ChapterFivePrinciple of subsidiarity.I.Case No.1 UnitedKingdom v.Council of the European Unior14II. Case No.2Germany v.Parliament & Council.1414III. Principle of subsidiarity.IV.Related Legal Issues.14.16Chapter Six Principleof Proportionality.CaseNo.1DanishBottles Case.16I.Basic information of the case.16.17II. analysis of the case..17III Related Legal Issues.-
欧洲联盟法经典案例课程（双语） 1 目 录 前 言.2 Chapter One Introduction.3 I. General introduction of European Communities .3 II. the Law of the European Union.3 III. Basic Institutions of EU .3 IV. Lisbon Treaty and European policies .4 Chapter Two IRAC-case analysis model.6 I.案例的基本结构（ Basic Structure of Ct Opinions ）.6 II. Content of the case analysis.6 III. Review and assess the case law.6 IV. Writing the Case Brief .6 Chapter Three Principle of direct effect ：Constitutional Administrative Aspects of EU Law .7 Section I. Principle of direct effect.7 Case No.1 Van Gend en Loos case : creation of direct effect principle .7 I. Significance.7 II. Basic information of the case .7 III. Holding.8 IV. Analysis- Principle of Direct Effect .8 Section 2 Later development of principle of direct effect .8 I. Case No.2 Defrenne case : horizontal direct effect.8 II. Case No.3 Fratelli Variola Case: Regulations and Direct Effect .9 III. Case No.3 Franz Grad Case: Decisions and Direct Effect.9 IV. Related Legal Issues .9 Chapter Four Principle of Primacy： Constitutional Administrative Aspects of EU Law. 11 Section 1 Principle of Primacy. 11 I. Basic information. 11 II. Holding. 11 III. Related Legal Issues.12 IV. The Principle of Supremacy .12 Section 2 Later development of principle of Primacy.12 I. Case No.2 Simmenthal case.12 II. Cassis de Dijon, Case 120/78 .12 III. Later development of principle of Primacy.12 Chapter Five Principle of subsidiarity.14 I．Case No. 1 United Kingdom v. Council of the European Union .14 II．Case No. 2 Germany v. Parliament & Council .14 III．Principle of subsidiarity.14 IV. Related Legal Issues .14 Chapter Six Principle of Proportionality.16 Case No.1 Danish Bottles Case.16 I. Basic information of the case.16 II. analysis of the case .17 III. Related Legal Issues.17
国际法学院专业课程教学大纲前言欧洲联盟法经典案例研究（CaseStudyonEuropeanUnionLaw）是法学本科阶段的选修课程，既是案例分析课，也是双语课程。本课程教学计划总计为36课时。本课程以欧洲一体化进程中的经典案例为主要教学内容，以共同体法律体系中的基本法律原则为轴心，选取涉及欧盟宪政、行政法、经济法和对外关系法等领域的经典案例，以欧洲法院做出的原始裁判为素材，研习欧洲法院的裁判、法律论证和推理，以及司法实践对欧洲一体化进程的影响。本课程采用中英文双语教学，学习材料为英文案例，通过讲授和讨论，以期达到以下几个方面的效果：1、通过学习欧洲联盟法的主要经典案例，使学生了解欧洲联盟的有关制度及其在实践中的演进，欧洲联盟法的基本内容、性质和特点；2、通过分析和研读欧洲法院处理的这些经典案例，使学生掌握相关法律原则，熟悉欧洲法院的司法独立及其对欧洲一体化进程的作用，了解欧洲法律传统；3、注重运用IRAC的分析和论证模式来分析欧盟法上的经典案例：侧重于法律问题的分析和推理，并进行相应练习，提升学生进行法律论证和分析的能力开拓学生的视野，提高对法律问题的探究能力；4、通过阅读欧洲联盟的主要经典案例原文，提高学生阅读和分析外文专业资料的能力，并初步掌握相关法律文书的写作技巧，为将来进一步学习和执业奠定一定基础。本教学大纲旨在列明本课程的主要知识点，由授课老师兰花编写。2
国际法学院专业课程教学大纲 2 前 言 欧洲联盟法经典案例研究（Case Study on European Union Law）是法学本科阶段的选修课程， 既是案例分析课，也是双语课程。本课程教学计划总计为 36 课时。 本课程以欧洲一体化进程中的经典案例为主要教学内容，以共同体法律体系中的基本法律原则 为轴心，选取涉及欧盟宪政、行政法、经济法和对外关系法等领域的经典案例，以欧洲法院做出的 原始裁判为素材，研习欧洲法院的裁判、法律论证和推理，以及司法实践对欧洲一体化进程的影响。 本课程采用中英文双语教学，学习材料为英文案例，通过讲授和讨论，以期达到以下几个方面 的效果： 1、通过学习欧洲联盟法的主要经典案例，使学生了解欧洲联盟的有关制度及其在实践中的演 进，欧洲联盟法的基本内容、性质和特点； 2、通过分析和研读欧洲法院处理的这些经典案例，使学生掌握相关法律原则，熟悉欧洲法院 的司法独立及其对欧洲一体化进程的作用，了解欧洲法律传统； 3、注重运用 IRAC 的分析和论证模式来分析欧盟法上的经典案例，侧重于法律问题的分析和 推理，并进行相应练习，提升学生进行法律论证和分析的能力开拓学生的视野，提高对法律问题的 探究能力； 4、通过阅读欧洲联盟的主要经典案例原文，提高学生阅读和分析外文专业资料的能力，并初 步掌握相关法律文书的写作技巧，为将来进一步学习和执业奠定一定基础。 本教学大纲旨在列明本课程的主要知识点，由授课老师兰花编写
欧洲联盟法经典案例课程（双语）Chapter One Introduction本章教学目的和基本要求：本章的教学目的体现为两方面：1、为便利后续课程的展开，介绍欧洲共同体法/欧洲联盟法的基本概念和制度，欧盟的机构框架，欧洲法院的管辖权；2、介绍学习欧洲联盟法的主要参考文献、资料和网址。学时分配：6学时。I.General introductionofEuropeanCommunities1.Origins of the community:The economic and political origins2.Thecommunityand its LaterDevelopment(1) Early Years of the Community,(2)EnlargementoftheCommunity(3)Evolution from Community to Union-TreatyestablishingtheEuropeanCoal and SteelCommunity,ECSCTreaty·Treaty establishing the European Economic Community, EEC Treaty-TreatyestablishingtheEuropeanAtomicEnergyCommunity(Euratom)II.the Law oftheEuropeanUnion1.Basicfacts of EuropeanUnion:three"pillars"(l)EClawaswellaseconomicinstitutions andactivities(2)CommonForeign and Security Policy(3)Justice andHomeAffairs2.Missions oftheEuropeanUnion3. Legal basis of EU() Treaty of Rome,(2)the SEA1986,(3) EU Treaty 1992-- Treaty of Maastricht(4)Treaty ofAmsterdam1997;(5)NiceTreaty2001(6)Lisbon Treaty 20094. Sources of EU law(I) primary law--constitutional treaties of EC/EU;(2)secondary law of EC/EU;a. regulations,b.directivesc. decisions(3) judicial precedents;(4) general principles.III.Basic Institutions of EU1.Council ofthe EU3
欧洲联盟法经典案例课程（双语） 3 Chapter One Introduction 本章教学目的和基本要求： 本章的教学目的体现为两方面：1、为便利后续课程的展开，介绍欧洲共同体法/欧洲联盟法的 基本概念和制度，欧盟的机构框架，欧洲法院的管辖权；2、介绍学习欧洲联盟法的主要参考文献、 资料和网址。 学时分配：6 学时。 I. General introduction of European Communities 1. Origins of the community: The economic and political origins 2. The community and its Later Development (1) Early Years of the Community; (2) Enlargement of the Community: (3) Evolution from Community to Union •Treaty establishing the European Coal and Steel Community, ECSC Treaty •Treaty establishing the European Economic Community, EEC Treaty •Treaty establishing the European Atomic Energy Community (Euratom) II. the Law of the European Union 1. Basic facts of European Union: three "pillars" (1) EC law as well as economic institutions and activities (2) Common Foreign and Security Policy (3) Justice and Home Affairs 2. Missions of the European Union 3. Legal basis of EU (1) Treaty of Rome, (2) the SEA 1986, (3) EU Treaty 1992- Treaty of Maastricht (4) Treaty of Amsterdam1997; (5) Nice Treaty 2001’ (6) Lisbon Treaty 2009 4. Sources of EU law (1) primary law-constitutional treaties of EC/EU; (2) secondary law of EC/EU; a. regulations, b. directives c. decisions (3) judicial precedents; (4) general principles. III. Basic Institutions of EU 1.Council of the EU
国际法学院专业课程教学大纲(1) Function(2) Responsibilities -----coordinates the activities of the Member States---- defining and implementing the common foreign and security policy2.European Commission(1) Function-initiator of proposals for legislation,·guardian of the Treaties,.manager and executor of EU policies and of international trade relations..(2) Responsibilities3.European Parliament(l) Function---Legislative power:Budgetary powersSupervision of the executive(2) Responsibilities4. The judicial system of EU(1)CompositionCourt of JusticeCourt of First Instance(2) Purpose(3) Jurisdiction5.TheHighRepresentativeof the UnionforForeignAffairs and SecurityPolicy6.TheotherinstitutionsandbodiesoftheUnionIV. Lisbon Treaty and European policies1.Decision-making process·The decision-making process under the second pillar-The decision-making process under the third pillar-Procedure for the adoption of international agreements?CooperationbetweentheEuropeanParliamentandtheEuropeanCommission·Theaccessionprocessfor a newMemberState2. European policies?Area of freedom, security and justice-Common Foreign and Security Policy-Common Security and Defence Policy-Economic and monetary policySocial policy·Energy-European Research Area and European Space Policy-Services of general interestThe new supporting competences ofthe EUEnd ofChapter AssessmentQuestion(1)What are the“European Community"and the“European Union"?4
国际法学院专业课程教学大纲 4 (1) Function (2) Responsibilities -coordinates the activities of the Member States - defining and implementing the common foreign and security policy 2.European Commission (1) Function- initiator of proposals for legislation; guardian of the Treaties; manager and executor of EU policies and of international trade relations. (2) Responsibilities 3.European Parliament (1) Function- Legislative power: Budgetary powers Supervision of the executive (2) Responsibilities 4. The judicial system of EU (1) Composition Court of Justice Court of First Instance (2) Purpose (3) Jurisdiction 5. The High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy 6.The other institutions and bodies of the Union IV. Lisbon Treaty and European policies 1. Decision-making process •The decision-making process under the second pillar •The decision-making process under the third pillar •Procedure for the adoption of international agreements •Cooperation between the European Parliament and the European Commission •The accession process for a new Member State 2. European policies •Area of freedom, security and justice •Common Foreign and Security Policy •Common Security and Defence Policy •Economic and monetary policy •Social policy •Energy •European Research Area and European Space Policy •Services of general interest •The new supporting competences of the EU End of Chapter Assessment Question (1) What are the “European Community” and the “European Union”?