Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016,15(3):528-536 Available online at www.sciencedirect.com A ScienceDirect ELSEVIER RESEARCH ARTICLE Isolation and characterization of an ERF-B3 gene associated with flower abnormalities in non-heading Chinese cabbage Cross Marl XU Yu-chao',HOU Xi-lin',XU Wei-wei',SHEN Lu-lu2,LU Shan-wu',ZHANG Shi-lin',HU Chun-mei' State Key Laboratory of Crop Genetics and Germplasm Enhancement,Ministry of Science and Technology/College of Horticulture,Nanjing Agricultural University,Nanjing 210095.P.R.China Agriculture Committee of Feixi County,Hefei 230001,P.R.China Abstract BrcERF-B3 gene,a member of ethylene-responsive factor family,was screened from a mutant plant in non-heading Chinese cabbage(Brassica rapa ssp.chinensis)by cDNA-AFLP technology.We got full length cDNA of two BrcERF-B3 genes by homology-based cloning from two materials and found that their nucleotide sequences were the same by sequencing.The BrcERF-B3 protein,belonging to the B3 subgroup of the ERF subfamily,shared a close relationship with B.rapa.RT-PCR result showed that BrcERF-B3 expressed only in mutant stamen rather than maintainer stamen.gRT-PCR results indicated that BrcERF-B3 expressed highly during reproductive growth development and in the early of mutant buds,suggesting BrcERF-B3 might be involved in the formation of abnormal flower in mutant.What's more,the expression of BrcERF-B3 was more significant to ABA,MeJA and cold stresses in mutant than in maintainer and was down-regulated in NaCI treatment in two lines,implying BrcERF-B3 might be different roles in biotic and abiotic stresses. Keywords:non-heading Chinese cabbage,stamen-petalody,ethylene-responsive factor,gene expression Plant flower architecture was controlled by some key players (such as transcription factors),some other reports showed 1.Introduction that homeotic conversion of stamens into petaloid structures in the basal Endicott Eschscholzia californica occurred Controlling the fertility was an important goal in crop hy- due to the knocking down of EScaAG1 and 2(Yellina et al. brid breeding.but it was difficult in some crops including 2010).The third and fourth whorls in androecium and non-heading Chinese cabbage.Most of phenotype of gynoecium had a homeotic transformation because of the male sterile lines(CMS or GMS)was instable,whereas the down-regulation of both PapsAG homologs concurrently stamen-dismissing material which was caused by stamen homologous transformation had a relatively stable sterility. (Hands et al.2011). AP2/ERF transcription factor,one of the largest plant transcription factor families,played a crucial role in plant growing and in response to biotic and abiotic stresses Received 12 January,2015 Accepted 8 October,2015 (Riechmannn et al.2000;Sakuma et a/.2002;Zhuang XU Yu-chao,E-mail:1049205908@qq.com; Correspondence HU Chun-mei,Tel:+86-25-84395756 et al.2008).The AP2/ERF superfamily was defined by the E-mail:jjjhcm@njau.edu.cn AP2/ERF domain,which consists about 60-70 amino acids 2016,CAAS.Published by Elsevier Ltd.This is an open and involved in DNA binding (Nakano et al.2006).Based access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http:/ on differences in the binding domain sequences,the AP2/ creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). doi10.1016/S2095-3119(15)61203-5
Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016, 15(3): 528–536 RESEARCH ARTICLE Available online at www.sciencedirect.com ScienceDirect Isolation and characterization of an ERF-B3 gene associated with flower abnormalities in non-heading Chinese cabbage XU Yu-chao1 , HOU Xi-lin1 , XU Wei-wei1 , SHEN Lu-lu2 , LÜ Shan-wu1 , ZHANG Shi-lin1 , HU Chun-mei1 1 State Key Laboratory of Crop Genetics and Germplasm Enhancement, Ministry of Science and Technology/College of Horticulture, Nanjing Agricultural University, Nanjing 210095, P.R.China 2 Agriculture Committee of Feixi County, Hefei 230001, P.R.China Abstract BrcERF-B3 gene, a member of ethylene-responsive factor family, was screened from a mutant plant in non-heading Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa ssp. chinensis) by cDNA-AFLP technology. We got full length cDNA of two BrcERF-B3 genes by homology-based cloning from two materials and found that their nucleotide sequences were the same by sequencing. The BrcERF-B3 protein, belonging to the B3 subgroup of the ERF subfamily, shared a close relationship with B. rapa. RT-PCR result showed that BrcERF-B3 expressed only in mutant stamen rather than maintainer stamen. qRT-PCR results indicated that BrcERF-B3 expressed highly during reproductive growth development and in the early of mutant buds, suggesting BrcERF-B3 might be involved in the formation of abnormal flower in mutant. What’s more, the expression of BrcERF-B3 was more significant to ABA, MeJA and cold stresses in mutant than in maintainer and was down-regulated in NaCl treatment in two lines, implying BrcERF-B3 might be different roles in biotic and abiotic stresses. Keywords: non-heading Chinese cabbage, stamen-petalody, ethylene-responsive factor, gene expression Plant flower architecture was controlled by some key players (such as transcription factors), some other reports showed that homeotic conversion of stamens into petaloid structures in the basal Endicott Eschscholzia californica occurred due to the knocking down of EScaAG1 and 2 (Yellina et al. 2010). The third and fourth whorls in androecium and gynoecium had a homeotic transformation because of the down-regulation of both PapsAG homologs concurrently (Hands et al. 2011). AP2/ERF transcription factor, one of the largest plant transcription factor families, played a crucial role in plant growing and in response to biotic and abiotic stresses (Riechmannn et al. 2000; Sakuma et al. 2002; Zhuang et al. 2008). The AP2/ERF superfamily was defined by the AP2/ERF domain, which consists about 60–70 amino acids and involved in DNA binding (Nakano et al. 2006). Based on differences in the binding domain sequences, the AP2/ Received 12 January, 2015 Accepted 8 October, 2015 XU Yu-chao, E-mail: 1049205908@qq.com; Correspondence HU Chun-mei, Tel: +86-25-84395756, E-mail: jjjhcm@njau.edu.cn doi: 10.1016/S2095-3119(15)61203-5 1. Introduction Controlling the fertility was an important goal in crop hybrid breeding, but it was difficult in some crops including non-heading Chinese cabbage. Most of phenotype of male sterile lines (CMS or GMS) was instable, whereas the stamen-dismissing material which was caused by stamen homologous transformation had a relatively stable sterility. © 2016, CAAS. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
XU Yu-chao et al.Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016,15(3):528-536 529 ERF superfamily can be grouped into five main subfamilies. 2.Results AP2,CBF/DREB,ERF,RAV and one soloist,At4g13040 (Sakuma et al.2002;Nakano et al.2006).They played a 2.1.Cloning the BrcERF-B3 cDNAs from cabbage different role in the regulation of the plant.and there was a mutual regulation relation among them (Zhao et al.2006). The BrcERF-B3 genes were cloned from two different cab- Ethylene-responsive transcription factors (ERFs)were bage lines (Fig.1),and both of their open reading frame firstly identified from tobacco as GCC box-binding proteins (ORF)fragments were 807 bp in length.The sequencing and could either induce or repress the expression of genes results showed that nucleotide sequences of two BrcERF-B3 containing the GCC box and related elements in their pro genes were identical. moters.Sequence analysis showed that ERFs contained a Based on the similarity of the amino acid sequences highly conserved,plant specific DNA-binding domain(DBD) of their DNA-binding domains(DBD),a phylogenetic tree consisting of 58-59 amino acids (Ohme-Takagi and Shinshi was created from the deduced amino acid sequences of 1995).At present,the percentage of total ERFgenes in all BrcERF-B3 and other ERF proteins from Arabidopsis.The the AP2/ERF family has been reported in several plants, result revealed that BrcERF-B3 belonged to the B3 group such as Arabidopsis(44.2%),populus trichocarpa(45.5%). of the ERF subfamily(Figs.2 and 3).The alignment of the Chinese cabbage (45.7%).Vitis vinifera(55%)and rice ERF-B3 showed that DBD of BrcERF-B3 shared a high (48.2%)(Sakuma et al.2002:Nakano et al.2006;Zhuang degree of sequence homology with ERF-B3 from other et al.2008.2009:Li et al.2013).Based on the sequence species.The DBD of BrcERF-B3 consisted of 3 anti-par- identities of their DBD,the ERF subfamily members can be allel B-sheet and 1 a-helix,besides,the F(phenylalanine) classified into six small subgroups(B1 through B6)(Sakuma in BrERF-B3 was replaced by T(threonine)in BrcERF-B3. etal.2002). N(asparagine)in BnERF-B3 was replaced by D(aspartic ERF family genes were reported mostly in responses to acid)in BrcERF-B3,respectively,these residues appeared biotic and abiotic stresses (Gutterson and Reuber 2004: to be responsible for binding specificity(Fig.4).BrcERF-B3 Kizis et al.2001).The group IX ERF genes in cotton may exhibited much greater similarity(95%)to those of BrERF- be involved in jasmonate (JA),ethylene (ET)responses B3(Fig.5). (Champion et al.2009).Arabidopsis ERF family mem- bers B3 subgroup AtERF98 regulated ABA synthesis and 2.2.Analysis of the expression of BrcERF-B3 gene involved in salt stress(Zhang et al.2012).It is reported that AtERF13 and AtERF15 regulate ABA response pos- BrcERF-B3 was completed at different leaf development itively (McGrath et al.2005),however,few researches stages by qRT-PCR.The gene expression profile presented associated with flower development have been found. in Fig.6 showed BrcERF-B3 notably increased during Ro- Non-heading Chinese cabbage(Brassica rapa ssp.chin- sette stage,then significantly decreased in maintainer line, ensis)is a cross-pollinated crop that is widely cultivated in East Asia.We created a stamen-petalody mutant line through chemical mutagenesis,in which stamens convert- ed into petaloid and flower turning into unisexual female flower.We previously obtained an ERF gene fragment by cDNA-AFLP technique,and it was named as BrcERF-B3 bp (not logged).However,the transcriptional regulatory 2000 function of BrcERF-B3 and its expression levels remains 1000 BrcERF-B3 unclear.In this study,we cloned the BrcERF-B3 gene 500 from the leaves and analyzed the expression levels of BrcERF-B3 in different organs in two lines.In addition, 250 we also analyzed the effects of BrcERF-B3 responses to 100 biotic and abiotic stresses.These results indicated that the expression level of BrcERF-B3 expressed only in mutant stamen at the early bud stage.The BrcERF-B3 existed different expression profiles in response to plant hormone, cold and NaCl treatments.These works will provide theoretical base for further studying stamen-petalody in Fig.1 The open reading frame of BrcERF-B3 amplification non-heading Chinese cabbage. products.M.DL2000 marker;1,mutant;2,maintainer
XU Yu-chao et al. Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016, 15(3): 528–536 529 ERF superfamily can be grouped into five main subfamilies, AP2, CBF/DREB, ERF, RAV and one soloist, At4g13040 (Sakuma et al. 2002; Nakano et al. 2006). They played a different role in the regulation of the plant, and there was a mutual regulation relation among them (Zhao et al. 2006). Ethylene-responsive transcription factors (ERFs) were firstly identified from tobacco as GCC box-binding proteins and could either induce or repress the expression of genes containing the GCC box and related elements in their promoters. Sequence analysis showed that ERFs contained a highly conserved, plant specific DNA-binding domain (DBD) consisting of 58–59 amino acids (Ohme-Takagi and Shinshi 1995). At present, the percentage of total ERF genes in all the AP2/ERF family has been reported in several plants, such as Arabidopsis (44.2%), populus trichocarpa (45.5%), Chinese cabbage (45.7%), Vitis vinifera (55%) and rice (48.2%) (Sakuma et al. 2002; Nakano et al. 2006; Zhuang et al. 2008, 2009; Li et al. 2013). Based on the sequence identities of their DBD, the ERF subfamily members can be classified into six small subgroups (B1 through B6) (Sakuma et al. 2002). ERF family genes were reported mostly in responses to biotic and abiotic stresses (Gutterson and Reuber 2004; Kizis et al. 2001). The group IX ERF genes in cotton may be involved in jasmonate (JA), ethylene (ET) responses (Champion et al. 2009). Arabidopsis ERF family members B3 subgroup AtERF98 regulated ABA synthesis and involved in salt stress (Zhang et al. 2012). It is reported that AtERF13 and AtERF15 regulate ABA response positively (McGrath et al. 2005), however, few researches associated with flower development have been found. Non-heading Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa ssp. chinensis) is a cross-pollinated crop that is widely cultivated in East Asia. We created a stamen-petalody mutant line through chemical mutagenesis, in which stamens converted into petaloid and flower turning into unisexual female flower. We previously obtained an ERF gene fragment by cDNA-AFLP technique, and it was named as BrcERF-B3 (not logged). However, the transcriptional regulatory function of BrcERF-B3 and its expression levels remains unclear. In this study, we cloned the BrcERF-B3 gene from the leaves and analyzed the expression levels of BrcERF-B3 in different organs in two lines. In addition, we also analyzed the effects of BrcERF-B3 responses to biotic and abiotic stresses. These results indicated that the expression level of BrcERF-B3 expressed only in mutant stamen at the early bud stage. The BrcERF-B3 existed different expression profiles in response to plant hormone, cold and NaCl treatments. These works will provide theoretical base for further studying stamen-petalody in non-heading Chinese cabbage. 2. Results 2.1. Cloning the BrcERF-B3 cDNAs from cabbage The BrcERF-B3 genes were cloned from two different cabbage lines (Fig. 1), and both of their open reading frame (ORF) fragments were 807 bp in length. The sequencing results showed that nucleotide sequences of two BrcERF-B3 genes were identical. Based on the similarity of the amino acid sequences of their DNA-binding domains (DBD), a phylogenetic tree was created from the deduced amino acid sequences of BrcERF-B3 and other ERF proteins from Arabidopsis. The result revealed that BrcERF-B3 belonged to the B3 group of the ERF subfamily (Figs. 2 and 3). The alignment of the ERF-B3 showed that DBD of BrcERF-B3 shared a high degree of sequence homology with ERF-B3 from other species. The DBD of BrcERF-B3 consisted of 3 anti-parallel β-sheet and 1 α-helix, besides, the F (phenylalanine) in BrERF-B3 was replaced by T (threonine) in BrcERF-B3, N (asparagine) in BnERF-B3 was replaced by D (aspartic acid) in BrcERF-B3, respectively, these residues appeared to be responsible for binding specificity (Fig. 4). BrcERF-B3 exhibited much greater similarity (95%) to those of BrERFB3 (Fig. 5). 2.2. Analysis of the expression of BrcERF-B3 gene BrcERF-B3 was completed at different leaf development stages by qRT-PCR. The gene expression profile presented in Fig. 6 showed BrcERF-B3 notably increased during Rosette stage, then significantly decreased in maintainer line, M bp 2 000 1000 750 500 250 100 1 2 BrcERF-B3 Fig. 1 The open reading frame of BrcERF-B3 amplification products. M, DL2000 marker; 1, mutant; 2, maintainer
530 XU Yu-chao et al.Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016,15(3):528-536 AtCBF1 91 AtCBF2 99 AtCBF3 AtDREB-A1 92 DREB AtDREB-A4 AtDREB-A5 AtDREB-A3 52 AtDREB-A2 AtDREB-A6 BrcERF-B3 99 AtERF1 AtERF2 99 AtERF5 AtERF6 ERF 99 AtERF3 68 AtERF7 AtERF9 84 99 AtERF4 AtERF8 AtAP2 AP2 100 AtRAV1 RAV AtRAV2 Fig.2 The phylogenetic analysis between BrcERF-B3 and the Arabidopsis thaliana AP2/ERF superfamily transcription factors. The phylogenetic tree was produced with the neighbor-joining method by the MEGA 5 software.The numbers above the branches indicated the reliability percent of bootstrap values from 1 000 replicates.BrcERF-B3 was boxed.The same as below. while the expression of BrcERF-B3 in mutant firstly subtly 2.3.Investigating the responses of BrcERF-B3 on decreased at rosette stage,then significantly increased,and different stresses keep a higher levels,suggested that BrcERF-B3 enhanced reproductive growth development.The expression profile of After ABA and MeJA treatments,similar trend were found BrcERF-B3 gene showed unobvious expression difference in expression of BrcERF-B3 in mutant and BrcERF-B3 was during flower development stages in maintainer line,but up-regulated and then down-regulated as time goes on.In the gene expressed significantly higher in mutant than in maintainer,the expression of BrcERF-B3 was decreased maintainer at the flower development(bud diameter <2 mm) compared to 0 h excepting at 1 h MeJA treatment.The stages indicated that BrcERF-B3 might enhance abnormal expression of BrcERF-B3 existed significant difference flower development in mutant(Fig.7). between maintainer line and mutant under ABA treatment RT-PCR was carried out on cDNA derived from floral and at 1,2,and 12 h MeJA treatment.During the cold organs to learn more about the BrcERF-B3 expression treatment,BrcERF-B3 gene initially increased at 1 h and profile.The results showed that BrcERF-B3 expressed subsequently slowly reached peaks at the transcription strongly in petal,stamen and carpal in mutant and slightly level at 4 and 2 h in mutant and maintainer,respectively. expressed in sepal,petal and carpel in maintainer.Partic- then decreased slowly.The expression of the gene in ularly.BrcERF-B3 expressed obviously higher in mutant mutant was significantly higher than in maintainer at 2-12 h. stamen than in maintainer stamen,which meant that The transcription levels of BrcERF-B3 in mutant and BrcERF-B3 gene acted a positive role in the formation of maintainer was obviously down-regulated in the NaCl mutant stamen (Fig.8). treatment (Fig.9)
530 XU Yu-chao et al. Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016, 15(3): 528–536 while the expression of BrcERF-B3 in mutant firstly subtly decreased at rosette stage, then significantly increased, and keep a higher levels, suggested that BrcERF-B3 enhanced reproductive growth development. The expression profile of BrcERF-B3 gene showed unobvious expression difference during flower development stages in maintainer line, but the gene expressed significantly higher in mutant than in maintainer at the flower development (bud diameter <2 mm) stages indicated that BrcERF-B3 might enhance abnormal flower development in mutant (Fig. 7). RT-PCR was carried out on cDNA derived from floral organs to learn more about the BrcERF-B3 expression profile. The results showed that BrcERF-B3 expressed strongly in petal, stamen and carpal in mutant and slightly expressed in sepal, petal and carpel in maintainer. Particularly, BrcERF-B3 expressed obviously higher in mutant stamen than in maintainer stamen, which meant that BrcERF-B3 gene acted a positive role in the formation of mutant stamen (Fig. 8). 2.3. Investigating the responses of BrcERF-B3 on different stresses After ABA and MeJA treatments, similar trend were found in expression of BrcERF-B3 in mutant and BrcERF-B3 was up-regulated and then down-regulated as time goes on. In maintainer, the expression of BrcERF-B3 was decreased compared to 0 h excepting at 1 h MeJA treatment. The expression of BrcERF-B3 existed significant difference between maintainer line and mutant under ABA treatment and at 1, 2, and 12 h MeJA treatment. During the cold treatment, BrcERF-B3 gene initially increased at 1 h and subsequently slowly reached peaks at the transcription level at 4 and 2 h in mutant and maintainer, respectively, then decreased slowly. The expression of the gene in mutant was significantly higher than in maintainer at 2–12 h. The transcription levels of BrcERF-B3 in mutant and maintainer was obviously down-regulated in the NaCl treatment (Fig. 9). Fig. 2 The phylogenetic analysis between BrcERF-B3 and the Arabidopsis thaliana AP2/ERF superfamily transcription factors. The phylogenetic tree was produced with the neighbor-joining method by the MEGA 5 software. The numbers above the branches indicated the reliability percent of bootstrap values from 1 000 replicates. BrcERF-B3 was boxed. The same as below
XU Yu-chao et al.Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016,15(3):528-536 531 AtERF104 AtERF105 AtERF5 AtERF6 DEWAX AtERF98 67 AIESE1 -AtESE14 B3 62 AtERF92 97 ORA59 AtERF15 AtERF13 92 AtERF2 AtERF1 96 RRTF1 BrcERF-B3 ABR1 AtRAP2.6 B4 AtRAP2.6L 81 AtRAP2.2 61 AtRAP2.12 AtERF71 B2 56 AtERF73 AtRAP2.3 AtERF10 61 AtESR1 AtESR2 99 LEP -PUCHI 16 AtERF7 B1 AtERF3 AtERF12 AtERF11 AtERF9 AtERF8 AtERF4 50 AtCRF3 AtCRF4 AtCRF2 AtCRF1 B5 AtCRF7 76 99 AtCRF8 AtCRF78 14 AtRAP2.11 AtSHINE1 84 AtESE3 AtSHINE3 AtCRF9 B6 94 AtCRF12 76 51 AtCRF10 AtCRF11 Fig.3 The phylogenetic analysis of BrcERF-B3 with each subgroup of ERF superfamily transcription factors from A.thaliana.The phylogenetic tree was produced with the neighbor-joining method by the MEGA 5 software
XU Yu-chao et al. Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016, 15(3): 528–536 531 Fig. 3 The phylogenetic analysis of BrcERF-B3 with each subgroup of ERF superfamily transcription factors from A. thaliana. The phylogenetic tree was produced with the neighbor-joining method by the MEGA 5 software
532 XU Yu-chao et al.Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016,15(3):528-536 Brassica rapa ssp.pekinensis Brassica rapa ssp.chinensis sica napus Eutrma salaugineum Capsella nbella Camelina sativa Arabidopsis lyrata subsp.lyrata Arabidopsis 33323388F Tarenaya hasslenana mnsps:r Brassica rapa ssp.pekinensis Brassica rapa ssp.chinensis Bra ssica napus Eutrma sala Camelina sativa Arabidopsis lyrata subsp.lyrata Arabidopsis thaliana 4464331455591454 Tarenaya hasslerian egg kirkr nkkng Brassica rapa ssp.pekinensis Brassica rapa ssp.chinensis ssica napu Eutrma salaugineum Capsella rbella Camelina sativa Arabidopsis lyrata subsp.lyrata Arabidopsis thaliana Tarenaya hassleriana arayd Brassica rapa ssp.pekinensis Brassica rapa ssp.chinensis Eutrma salaugineum CaDs8a几bea Camelina sativa Arabidopsis lyrata subsp.lyrata Arabidopsis thaliana 0招新新 Tarenaya hasslenana Fig.4 Alignment of the conserved ERF signatures of BrcERF-B3 with other ERF-B3 from different plants.The identical amino acid residues were indicated with black background,while 75%conservation was marked as gray.The deduced motifs(3 B-sheets and 1 a-helix)were marked. 98 Capsella rubella Camlina sativa 100 Arabidopsis lyrata subsp.lyrata Arabidopsis thaliana Eutrema salsugineum 100 Brassica napus 95 Brassica rapa ssp.pekinensis Brassica rapa ssp.chinensis Tarenaya hassleriana Fig.5 The homology tree was conducted to show the relationships of ERF-B3 among different plants. 3.Discussion the nucleotide sequences of two BrcERF-B3 genes were identical between these two lines.The phylogenetic tree Non-heading Chinese cabbage is an important crop in revealed that BrcERF-B3 belonged to the ERF-B3 subfamily. eastern Asia.Stamen-petalody is a novel type of male which is similar to the result study that most of 77 encoding sterility in non-heading Chinese cabbage.In this study,we ERF-like proteins of ERF superfamily belonging to B3 in rice cloned the full-ORF cDNA sequences of BrcERF-B3 from (Sharoni et al.2011).The DBD of BrcERF-B3 protein,which two non-heading Chinese cabbage lines and discovered that contained 3 anti-parallel B-sheet and 1 a-helix,combined
532 XU Yu-chao et al. Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2016, 15(3): 528–536 3. Discussion Non-heading Chinese cabbage is an important crop in eastern Asia. Stamen-petalody is a novel type of male sterility in non-heading Chinese cabbage. In this study, we cloned the full-ORF cDNA sequences of BrcERF-B3 from two non-heading Chinese cabbage lines and discovered that the nucleotide sequences of two BrcERF-B3 genes were identical between these two lines. The phylogenetic tree revealed that BrcERF-B3 belonged to the ERF-B3 subfamily, which is similar to the result study that most of 77 encoding ERF-like proteins of ERF superfamily belonging to B3 in rice (Sharoni et al. 2011). The DBD of BrcERF-B3 protein, which contained 3 anti-parallel β-sheet and 1 α-helix, combined Fig. 4 Alignment of the conserved ERF signatures of BrcERF-B3 with other ERF-B3 from different plants. The identical amino acid residues were indicated with black background, while 75% conservation was marked as gray. The deduced motifs (3 β-sheets and 1 α-helix) were marked. Fig. 5 The homology tree was conducted to show the relationships of ERF-B3 among different plants