Copyrighted Materials Copyright 2009 DEStech Publications Retrieved from www.knovel.con CHAPTER6 Pultrusion 1. GENERAL Pultrusion is a manufacturing process that combines many steps in the manufacturing of composites into two steps. Refer to Figure 1.7(a) of Chapter 1. That figure shows four steps in the manufacturing process. Figure 6.1 shows a representation of the pultrusion process. For pultrusion, one goes directly from step a to step d, and one does not have intermediate products in between. . Step a: Beginning from the left-hand side, the fiber tows drawn from fiber racks are routed through a series of guides. The fibers then traverse through a bath of low viscosity resin for impregnation. . Step d: Upon exiting from the resin bath, fibers are collimated into an aligned bundle before entering into a heated die. While inside the die, the following takes place: -The resin flows and wets the fibers. -The ensemble of fibers and resin is compacted. -The resin cures and the fiber/resin system becomes solid. Upon exiting from the die, the composite structural component is pulled by a puller. It is then cut to length and is ready for ship- ment. Since the pultrusion process combines many steps into one, the oppor- tunity for checking the quality is reduced. Also the requirements for con- 233
CHAPTER 6 1. GENERAL Pultrusion is a manufacturing process that combines many steps in the manufacturing of composites into two steps. Refer to Figure 1.7(a) of Chapter 1. That figure shows four steps in the manufacturing process. Figure 6.1 shows a representation of the pultrusion process. For pultrusion, one goes directly from step a to step d, and one does not have intermediate products in between. • Step a: Beginning from the left-hand side, the fiber tows drawn from fiber racks are routed through a series of guides. The fibers then traverse through a bath of low viscosity resin for impregnation. • Step d: Upon exiting from the resin bath, fibers are collimated into an aligned bundle before entering into a heated die. While inside the die, the following takes place: —The resin flows and wets the fibers. —The ensemble of fibers and resin is compacted. —The resin cures and the fiber/resin system becomes solid. Upon exiting from the die, the composite structural component is pulled by a puller. It is then cut to length and is ready for shipment. Since the pultrusion process combines many steps into one, the opportunity for checking the quality is reduced. Also the requirements for con- 233
234 PULTRUSION trol of quality are increased to ensure good quality.However,pultrusion offers a fast production rate.The production rate can be in terms of me- ters per minute.It can also produce composite parts at low cost.This is because fibers in tow form are less expensive than in prepreg or woven form.The rule is that if more processing is involved in transforming the fiber,either by wetting with the resin or in changing the form from unidi- rectional tows to woven or braids,cost and time are involved.As such. pultrusion has been used to produce many low cost composite structural elements,if strict quality is not a requirement.However there are also limitations.One of the main limitations is that the fibers are mostly unidi- rectional. By pultrusion,many lightweight,corrosion resistant and low electrical conductivity components can be made.These include standard shapes such as rods,angles,clips,I beams,panels,plates,and rebars for con- crete reinforcement.Other components include side rails for ladders, fishing rods,tool handles,bus components,sign posts,and sucker rods for oil drilling rigs. Due to the low cost of the process,E glass fibers are mostly used even though applications include fibers such as S glass,carbon,and Kevlar. Resins are usually low cost polyester or vinyl ester even though other res- ins such as epoxy,phenolic and thermoplastic have also been used. There are two forms of pultrusion products.The first category con- sists of solid rod and bar stock produced from axial fiberglass rein- forcements and polyester resins.These are used to make fishing rods and electrical insulator rods,which require high axial strength.The second category is structural profiles,which use a combination of axial Fiber racks cloth racks material guides pulling mechanisms pultrusion moving engaged disengaged die cutofl saw hydraulic rams finished prelorming guides resin tank product FIGURE 6.I Schematic of the pultrusion process(reproduced from"Pultrusion of com- posites,"by J.P.Fanucci,S.Nolet,and S.McCarthy,in Advanced Composites Manufac- furing by T.G.Gutowski,1997,with permission from John Wiley and Sons)
trol of quality are increased to ensure good quality. However, pultrusion offers a fast production rate. The production rate can be in terms of meters per minute. It can also produce composite parts at low cost. This is because fibers in tow form are less expensive than in prepreg or woven form. The rule is that if more processing is involved in transforming the fiber, either by wetting with the resin or in changing the form from unidirectional tows to woven or braids, cost and time are involved. As such, pultrusion has been used to produce many low cost composite structural elements, if strict quality is not a requirement. However there are also limitations. One of the main limitations is that the fibers are mostly unidirectional. By pultrusion, many lightweight, corrosion resistant and low electrical conductivity components can be made. These include standard shapes such as rods, angles, clips, I beams, panels, plates, and rebars for concrete reinforcement. Other components include side rails for ladders, fishing rods, tool handles, bus components, sign posts, and sucker rods for oil drilling rigs. Due to the low cost of the process, E glass fibers are mostly used even though applications include fibers such as S glass, carbon, and Kevlar. Resins are usually low cost polyester or vinyl ester even though other resins such as epoxy, phenolic and thermoplastic have also been used. There are two forms of pultrusion products. The first category consists of solid rod and bar stock produced from axial fiberglass reinforcements and polyester resins. These are used to make fishing rods and electrical insulator rods, which require high axial strength. The second category is structural profiles, which use a combination of axial 234 PULTRUSION FIGURE 6.1 Schematic of the pultrusion process (reproduced from “Pultrusion of composites,” by J. P. Fanucci, S. Nolet, and S. McCarthy, in Advanced Composites Manufacturing by T.G. Gutowski, 1997, with permission from John Wiley and Sons)
Materials 235 fibers and multidirectional fiber mats to increase a set of properties that meet the requirements of the application in the transverse and longitu- dinal directions. 2.MATERIALS 2.1.Fibers 2.1.1.Unidirectional Rovings Fiberglass is the most commonly used fiber for pultrusion.Unidirec- tional fibers are the least expensive reinforcements available.Most pultruded profiles are used in structural applications where loading is highly oriented along the length of the profile.Unidirectional loading minimizes friction drag in the die,provides the highest pulling strength possible,and simplifies the design and fabrication of forming guides at the entrance of the die. The combination of cost,design applicability,and manufacturing ease make unidirectional rovings the most widely used reinforcement in pultrusion processing.Unidirectional filaments in the form of rovings, tows or threads are the building blocks for virtually all other reinforcement forms. For most practical applications,the use of all-unidirectional rovings is unrealistic.The highly orthotropic behavior of the unidirectional com- posite results in transverse properties that are much too low.Parts con- structed this way might have unacceptable resistance to crushing or splitting parallel to the fiber direction.Some means of providing strength in the transverse direction is often mandatory. 2.1.2.Woven and Nonwoven Broad Goods Low cost commercial pultrusions made of unidirectional glass rovings often include inexpensive forms of nonwoven broad goods called contin- uous strands and chopped strand mat.The random orientation of these materials provides some degree of off-axis strength and stiffness en- hancement at very low cost.Woven materials used in the pultrusion pro- cess must be placed between more stable forms such as layers of unidirectional rovings.Figures 6.2 and 6.3 show the incorporation of mats along with unidirectional rovings. When more complicated laminates are required,cloth,random mats, and preplied fabrics can be added to obtain transverse and off-axis rein-
fibers and multidirectional fiber mats to increase a set of properties that meet the requirements of the application in the transverse and longitudinal directions. 2. MATERIALS 2.1. Fibers 2.1.1. Unidirectional Rovings Fiberglass is the most commonly used fiber for pultrusion. Unidirectional fibers are the least expensive reinforcements available. Most pultruded profiles are used in structural applications where loading is highly oriented along the length of the profile. Unidirectional loading minimizes friction drag in the die, provides the highest pulling strength possible, and simplifies the design and fabrication of forming guides at the entrance of the die. The combination of cost, design applicability, and manufacturing ease make unidirectional rovings the most widely used reinforcement in pultrusion processing. Unidirectional filaments in the form of rovings, tows or threads are the building blocks for virtually all other reinforcement forms. For most practical applications, the use of all-unidirectional rovings is unrealistic. The highly orthotropic behavior of the unidirectional composite results in transverse properties that are much too low. Parts constructed this way might have unacceptable resistance to crushing or splitting parallel to the fiber direction. Some means of providing strength in the transverse direction is often mandatory. 2.1.2. Woven and Nonwoven Broad Goods Low cost commercial pultrusions made of unidirectional glass rovings often include inexpensive forms of nonwoven broad goods called continuous strands and chopped strand mat. The random orientation of these materials provides some degree of off-axis strength and stiffness enhancement at very low cost. Woven materials used in the pultrusion process must be placed between more stable forms such as layers of unidirectional rovings. Figures 6.2 and 6.3 show the incorporation of mats along with unidirectional rovings. When more complicated laminates are required, cloth, random mats, and preplied fabrics can be added to obtain transverse and off-axis reinMaterials 235
236 PULTRUSION ROVING RESIN BATH CONTINUOUS MAT PULLER MANDREL PREFORMING DIES- RESIN BATH HEATED DIE- CONTINUOUS MAT FIGURE 6.2 Introduction of mats into the pultruded products (reproduced from Hand- book of Pultrusion Technology,by R.W.Meyer,with permission from Springer). forcing.Fiber tension is not a severe problem for commonly pultruded constructions composed primarily of unidirectional tows.Problems be- gin to occur in more sophisticated applications when broad goods and other off-axis reinforcements are included in the laminate.If not prop- erly handled,these laminates tend to distort and deform as they are folded during assembly outside the die,and can be further distorted when dragged along the tooling surfaces inside the die. 2.2.Resins The necessary characteristics for a resin to be used to make pultruded products are that it have low viscosity and that gel time and cure time SURFACING MAT CONTINUOUS STRAND MAT- Xg人XA ROVING 2002p99900 CONTINUOUS STRAND MAT au0Q史 ROVING PULTRUSION COMPOSITE CONTINUOUS STRAND MAT 海YX效 URFACING MAT FIGURE 6.3 Exploded view of materials in pultrusion (reproduced from Handbook of Pultrusion Technology,by R.W.Meyer,with permission from Springer)
forcing. Fiber tension is not a severe problem for commonly pultruded constructions composed primarily of unidirectional tows. Problems begin to occur in more sophisticated applications when broad goods and other off-axis reinforcements are included in the laminate. If not properly handled, these laminates tend to distort and deform as they are folded during assembly outside the die, and can be further distorted when dragged along the tooling surfaces inside the die. 2.2. Resins The necessary characteristics for a resin to be used to make pultruded products are that it have low viscosity and that gel time and cure time 236 PULTRUSION FIGURE 6.3 Exploded view of materials in pultrusion (reproduced from Handbook of Pultrusion Technology, by R. W. Meyer, with permission from Springer). FIGURE 6.2 Introduction of mats into the pultruded products (reproduced from Handbook of Pultrusion Technology, by R. W. Meyer, with permission from Springer)
Materials 237 are short to allow for the high rate of production.If,for example,a rate of production of 20 cm/minute is desired,for the length of a die of 100 cm long,the duration of the resin inside the mold is 5 minutes.The resin should flow through the interstices of the tows,wet the fibers,gel and cure during this time.When the resin gels,it also shrinks,which helps to release the composite from the die wall.This,in turn,will reduce the pulling force.The resin normally used to make pultruded products is polyester resin,due to its low cost and low viscosity.Table 6.1 shows the viscosity of polyester resin along with gel time and cure time.When better corrosion resistance is required,vinyl ester resins are used. When a combination of superior mechanical and electrical properties is required,epoxy resin is used.Epoxy resins are expensive materials in a number of aspects.The resins are three to six times more expensive than polyesters and have a number of process-related costs not found with polyesters.Because they are cured by a stepwise reaction rather than an addition reaction,as with polyester resins,their reaction rate is very slow.The gelation of epoxy resins occurs at a later stage of reac- tion,and it is critical that the exotherm developed be contained within the die.This dictates a slow reaction rate,which results in a high labor. Because the epoxy begins to react slowly as soon as it is mixed,the pot life is short.The resin scrap rate is potentially higher if viscosity buildup affects wet-out to the extent that the bath must be recharged. The die temperature profiles used for epoxy are typically hotter than polyesters,and the drip-off at the entrance must often be discarded rather than recirculated to the bath.Because of the tendency for the ep- oxy resin to bond strongly to the die wall,epoxy products often display surface defects,such as exposed fibers,chipping,or loss of dimension, all of which increase finished-product scrap rate.These additional costs place epoxy resins in a class in which the end-use requirements must justify the high price [1]. TABLE 6.1 General Properties of Polyester Resins Used for Pultrusion. Property Value Viscosity at 25C(cP) 500-2000 Specific gravity 1.1 Gel time (minutes) 3-8 Cure time (minutes) 5-18 Peak exotherm (max temperature 415-470℉(213-243°C) during the process)
are short to allow for the high rate of production. If, for example, a rate of production of 20 cm/minute is desired, for the length of a die of 100 cm long, the duration of the resin inside the mold is 5 minutes. The resin should flow through the interstices of the tows, wet the fibers, gel and cure during this time. When the resin gels, it also shrinks, which helps to release the composite from the die wall. This, in turn, will reduce the pulling force. The resin normally used to make pultruded products is polyester resin, due to its low cost and low viscosity. Table 6.1 shows the viscosity of polyester resin along with gel time and cure time. When better corrosion resistance is required, vinyl ester resins are used. When a combination of superior mechanical and electrical properties is required, epoxy resin is used. Epoxy resins are expensive materials in a number of aspects. The resins are three to six times more expensive than polyesters and have a number of process-related costs not found with polyesters. Because they are cured by a stepwise reaction rather than an addition reaction, as with polyester resins, their reaction rate is very slow. The gelation of epoxy resins occurs at a later stage of reaction, and it is critical that the exotherm developed be contained within the die. This dictates a slow reaction rate, which results in a high labor. Because the epoxy begins to react slowly as soon as it is mixed, the pot life is short. The resin scrap rate is potentially higher if viscosity buildup affects wet-out to the extent that the bath must be recharged. The die temperature profiles used for epoxy are typically hotter than polyesters, and the drip-off at the entrance must often be discarded rather than recirculated to the bath. Because of the tendency for the epoxy resin to bond strongly to the die wall, epoxy products often display surface defects, such as exposed fibers, chipping, or loss of dimension, all of which increase finished-product scrap rate. These additional costs place epoxy resins in a class in which the end-use requirements must justify the high price [1]. Materials 237 TABLE 6.1 General Properties of Polyester Resins Used for Pultrusion. Property Value Viscosity at 25°C (cP) 500–2000 Specific gravity 1.1 Gel time (minutes) 3–8 Cure time (minutes) 5–18 Peak exotherm (max temperature during the process) 415–470°F (213–243°C)