Introduction session 10 Neurodegenerative diseases and ubiquitin-proteasome syster to copyright considerations See Figure chanover, A and Brundin, P. 2003. The ubiquitin proteasome enerative diseases: sometimes the chicken, sometimes the egg Neuron 40: The UPS and The figure describes four different aspects related to protein misfolding and neurodegenerative diseases (1)Triggers that can cause the accumulation of misfolded proteins-these include both mutations and epigenetic factors (2) The primary responses to accumulating misfolded proteins-these are related to the reduced capacity of the uPs that is the consequence of protein overload/inhibition by aggregated substrates, The misfolded proteins that accumulate may be refolded by chaperones or accumulate in aggregates in the cytoplasm, nucleus, or extracellular space, The aggregates may equester additional proteins 3)Types of neuropathological extracellular and intracellular protein deposits that can be found in the central nervous system of patients with PD, AD, Prion disease, ALS, and polyglutamine(Poly Q) disorders Finally, (4)four secondary disease targets, i.e., the different cell functions that are affected by ional disease. In different protein conformation disorders, it has been shown that gene transcription can be markedly disturbed at the levels of histone regulation and individual transcription factors. There is evidence for disrupted axonal transport of different cell constituents. At the presynaptic ansmitter synthesis can be impaired; vesicular storage is sometimes disrupted; proteins involved in vesicle cycling are altered. At the postsynaptic level, the misfolded proteins can change densities and downstream signaling transduction pathways, Finally, the diseases can ause neuronal death by several mechanisms, including impairment of mitochondrial function and mitochondrial release of ytochrome c with subsequent caspase activation. It has also been suggested that aberrant protein folding can lead to pore formation in cell membranes and loss of ionic homeostasis Parkinson's disease(PD described in various rare forms of hereditary PD that shed light on basic pathogenic In PD, the main neuropathological feature is mechanisms that maybe relevant also to the the progressive death of neurons in the most prevalent late-onset and sporadic cases substantia nigra pars compacta with resulting loss of dopaminergic innervation of the striatum. This causes a gradual An important player in the pathogenesis of PD development of akinesia, rigidity, and is Parkin (PARK2). Parkin is a protein with a tremor In the vast majority of patients, some UBL domain at the N-terminal region and two of the remaining nigral dopaminergic neurons RING finger motifs at the carboxy-terminc exhibit aggregated proteins in the form of region, identified as an ubiquitin- E3 ligase cytoplasmic LB (Lewy Body) inclusions that acts along with the ubiquitin-conjugating Several apparently independent aberrations enzymes UbcH7 and UbcH8, Various delet linked to defects in the ups have been and point mutations in the gene have been
Introduction Session 10 “Neurodegenerative diseases and ubiquitin-proteasome system” Image removed due to copyright considerations. See Figure 2 in Ciechanover, A. and Brundin, P. 2003. The ubiquitin proteasome system in neurodegenerative diseases: sometimes the chicken, sometimes the egg. Neuron 40: 427-446. The UPS and Pathogenesis of Neurodegeneration The figure describes four different aspects related to protein misfolding and neurodegenerative diseases: (1) Triggers that can cause the accumulation of misfolded proteins—these include both mutations and epigenetic factors. (2) The primary responses to accumulating misfolded proteins—these are related to the reduced capacity of the UPS that is the consequence of protein overload/inhibition by aggregated substrates. The misfolded proteins that accumulate may be refolded by chaperones or accumulate in aggregates in the cytoplasm, nucleus, or extracellular space. The aggregates may sequester additional proteins. (3) Types of neuropathological extracellular and intracellular protein deposits that can be found in the central nervous system of patients with PD, AD, Prion disease, ALS, and polyglutamine (PolyQ) disorders. Finally, (4) four secondary disease targets, i.e., the different cell functions that are affected by the protein conformational disease. In different protein conformation disorders, it has been shown that gene transcription can be markedly disturbed at the levels of histone regulation and individual transcription factors. There is evidence for disrupted axonal transport of different cell constituents. At the presynaptic level, neurotransmitter synthesis can be impaired; vesicular storage is sometimes disrupted; proteins involved in vesicle cycling are altered. At the postsynaptic level, the misfolded proteins can change receptor densities and downstream signaling transduction pathways. Finally, the diseases can cause neuronal death by several mechanisms, including impairment of mitochondrial function and mitochondrial release of cytochrome c with subsequent caspase activation. It has also been suggested that aberrant protein folding can lead to pore formation in cell membranes and loss of ionic homeostasis. Parkinson’s disease (PD) In PD, the main neuropathological feature is the progressive death of neurons in the substantia nigra pars compacta with resulting loss of dopaminergic innervation of the striatum. This causes a gradual development of akinesia, rigidity, and tremor. In the vast majority of patients, some of the remaining nigral dopaminergic neurons exhibit aggregated proteins in the form of cytoplasmic LB (Lewy Body) inclusions. Several apparently independent aberrations linked to defects in the UPS have been described in various rare forms of hereditary PD that shed light on basic pathogenic mechanisms that maybe relevant also to the most prevalent late-onset and sporadic cases of PD. An important player in the pathogenesis of PD is Parkin (PARK2). Parkin is a protein with a UBL domain at the N-terminal region and two RING finger motifs at the carboxy-terminal region, identified as an ubiquitin- E3 ligase that acts along with the ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes UbcH7 and UbcH8. Various deletion and point mutations in the gene have been
found in around 50% of the patients with AR JP ( Juvenile or early-onset Parkinsonism) Parkin-associated endothelial-like also known as Autosomal Recessive Parkinsons receptor(PaeI) receptor, putative G Disease [ARPD], one of the most common familial forms of PD. Interestingly, with a few polypeptide. When overexpressed exceptions, AR-JP is characterized by a lack aggregates and parkin can ubiquitinate of lBs and target it for its degradation. Its accumulation elicits cell-death The RING finger domain is involved, most promoted by the activation of the probably, in recruitment of the E2 component Unfolded Protein Response (UPR)in of the ubiquitination machinery, while the UBL the ER (a stress-responsive pathway that increases biosynthesis of facilitating transfer of the polyubiquitinated in response to substrate(s) to the degrading machinery. It accumulation misfolded/ appears that Parkin serves as a common, RING denatured/mutated proteins in this finger-containing component shared by organelle). group of putative, yet to be discovered, SCl (overexpression of Parkin can like complexes. Most of the point mutations rescue cells from the UPR elicited described in Parkin reside in its RING-IBR by a variety of stresses(H202 (In Between-RINGS)-RING domain and UV, osmolarity, heat shock, etc) result in its inactivation. Some mutations may fact that also suggests its role in reduce the activity of the enzyme (the clearing up cells from certain autocatalytic one and/or the one displayed toward the exogenous substrates)whereas others may affect other mechanisms, such as interaction of the E3 with essential partners a-synuclein (asyN) and its associated protein Synphilin-1 A crucially important development in our proteins of yet unclear role but found nderstanding of parkin function is the n protein inclusions(LBs)in patients identification of its native cellular with sporadic, late-onset PD. substrates. The overriding hypothesis is that a defect in parkin will result in accumulation of this protein(s), which is toxic to the dopamine dopaminergic neurons. Several substrates have neurotransmission/release via been identified that are ubiquitinated by effects on vesicular storage Parkin, yet it is not clear whether is the Wild-typ aSyN accumulation of one or several of these monomeric but at high proteins that underlies the pathogenesis of concentrations this familial form of PD oligomerizes to B-pleated sheets known as protofibrils Identified substrates for Parkin: These can further aggregate precipitate myloid Cell Division Control related protein fibrils that are present in (CDCrel-1), very likely involved in the the Lewy Bodies(hallmark of regulation of transmitter release via its role in regular Mutations in the nonglycosilated 14 dynamics. Parkin also has other aSyN are related to the pathogenesis of potential substrates related to PD but, in particular, a novel 22 kDa form such as synaptotagmin D been found to be a direct substrate for filaments parkin. Since aSp22 accumulates in a
found in around 50% of the patients with ARJP (Juvenile or early-onset Parkinsonism), also known as Autosomal Recessive Parkinson’s Disease [ARPD]), one of the most common familial forms of PD. Interestingly, with a few exceptions, AR-JP is characterized by a lack of LBs. The RING finger domain is involved, most probably, in recruitment of the E2 component of the ubiquitination machinery, while the UBL serves as a proteasome binding thus facilitating transfer of the polyubiquitinated substrate(s) to the degrading machinery. It appears that Parkin serves as a common, RING finger-containing component shared by a group of putative, yet to be discovered, SCFlike complexes. Most of the point mutations described in Parkin reside in its RING-IBR- (In Between-RINGS)-RING domain and result in its inactivation. Some mutations may reduce the activity of the enzyme (the autocatalytic one and/or the one displayed toward the exogenous substrates) whereas others may affect other mechanisms, such as interaction of the E3 with essential partners. A crucially important development in our understanding of Parkin function is the identification of its native cellular substrates. The overriding hypothesis is that a defect in Parkin will result in accumulation of this protein(s), which is toxic to the dopaminergic neurons. Several substrates have been identified that are ubiquitinated by Parkin, yet it is not clear whether is the accumulation of one or several of these proteins that underlies the pathogenesis of this familial form of PD. Identified substrates for Parkin: • Cell Division Control related protein (CDCrel-1), very likely involved in the regulation of transmitter release via its role in regulating synaptic vesicle dynamics. Parkin also has other potential substrates related to synaptic transmission, such as synaptotagmin IX and actin filaments. • Parkin-associated endothelial-like receptor (PaeI) receptor, putative G protein-coupled transmembrane polypeptide. When overexpressed, aggregates and parkin can ubiquitinate and target it for its degradation. Its accumulation elicits cell-death promoted by the activation of the Unfolded Protein Response (UPR) in the ER (a stress-responsive pathway that increases biosynthesis of chaperones in response to accumulation of misfolded/ denatured/mutated proteins in this organelle). **(overexpression of Parkin can rescue cells from the UPR elicited by a variety of stresses (H2O2, UV, osmolarity, heat shock, etc), fact that also suggests its role in clearing up cells from certain proteins that are toxic when accumulate). • α-synuclein (αSYN) and its associated protein Synphilin-1, proteins of yet unclear role but found in protein inclusions (LBs) in patients with sporadic, late-onset PD. o αSYN is thought to regulate/participate in dopamine neurotransmission/release via effects on vesicular storage. Wild-type αSYN is monomeric but at high concentrations, it oligomerizes to β-pleated sheets known as protofibrils. These can further aggregate and precipitate as amyloid fibrils that are present in the Lewy Bodies (hallmark of sporadic, late-onset PD). Mutations in the nonglycosilated 14 kDa αSYN are related to the pathogenesis of PD but, in particular, a novel 22 kDa form of O-glycosilated αSYN (αSp22) has been found to be a direct substrate for parkin. Since αSp22 accumulates in a
nonubiquitinated form only in the brains of oligomeric state)and in protection from patients with AR-JP, this accumulation oxidative damage (DJ-1 protein), with may be toxic. This along with the lack of mutations associated to PD LBs in this kind of pd has led to the hypothesis that ubiquitination of proteins Summarizing, in cases with non-apparent may play a role in their aggregation and familial genetic defects associated, along with precipitation into inclusion bodies an age-related tendency to accumulate oxidized damaged proteins, failure of the protective role to momentarily get ou UPS remove the way protein aggregates of insoluble, misfolded/abnormal proteins may une potentially toxic effect, if for any reason the degeneration of nigral cells in sporadic the proteasome is overwhelmed"and disease. Proteolytic stress with an cannot immediately act on their removal accompanying defect in protein handling is and at this regard it is noteworthy that crucial and the substantia nigra neurons are both monomeric and aggregated asyN ca particularly vulnerable due to their high bind to the proteasome and inhibit its content of dopamine. And this vulnerability is function if in excess-). In AR-JP, parkin is very likely due to the high basal rate of biquitination of all its substrates enzymatic and autooxidative machineries Therefore the cells cannot accumulate involved in dopamine oxidation them in LBs Cyclin E, p38 aminoacyl-tRNA complex, are yet recently- found substrates for parkin hose accumulation leads neuro Besides parkin and its substrates, there are yet other recently-di ed proteins playing roles in both protein degradation by the UPS (the Ub C-terminal hydrolase UCH-L1, which displays both polyubiquitinating activities depending on its Alzheimers disease (AD) The plaques in Ad are rich in amyloid B peptides (aB) that produced by In AD, the dominant sympt dementia lytic initially characterized by a loss of short-term precursor peptide(APP), a glycolipid located memory which gradually develops into a loss in the outer cell membrane. Three different of most higher faculties. Patients with A proteases, called a, B, and Y secretases, can display two types of protein deposits cleave APP at specific sites. Concomitant extracellular amyloi plaques and cleavage of APP by B and y secretase at intracellular neurofibrillary tangles. The specific sites can result in fragments that can atter neuropathological change is also misfold and form extracellular fibrils. These observed in a series of other neurological fibrils consist of B sheets. It is debated conditions that have been collectively named whether the fibrils are toxic through tauopathies and include some forms of formation of pores or whether th Parkinsonism, Picks disease, and boxing- extracellular amyloid deposits are the main induced dementia( Dementia pugilistica) culprits. The AB in plaques arises from specific
nonubiquitinated form only in the brains of patients with AR-JP, this accumulation may be toxic. This along with the lack of LBs in this kind of PD has led to the hypothesis that ubiquitination of proteins may play a role in their aggregation and precipitation into inclusion bodies (the inclusions may even have a primary protective role to momentarily ‘get out of the way’ protein aggregates of insoluble, potentially toxic effect, if for any reason the proteasome is “overwhelmed” and cannot immediately act on their removal – and at this regard it is noteworthy that both monomeric and aggregated αSYN can bind to the proteasome and inhibit its function if in excess-). In AR-JP, parkin is usually inactivated and cannot act in the ubiquitination of all its substrates. Therefore the cells cannot accumulate them in LBs. • Cyclin E, p38 subunit of the aminoacyl-tRNA complex, are yet recently- found substrates for parkin whose accumulation leads also to neuronal apoptosis. Besides parkin and its substrates, there are yet other recently-discovered proteins playing roles in both protein degradation by the UPS (the Ub C-terminal hydrolase UCH-L1, which displays both deubiquitinating and polyubiquitinating activities depending on its Alzheimer’s disease (AD) In AD, the dominant symptom is dementia, initially characterized by a loss of short-term memory which gradually develops into a loss of most higher faculties. Patients with AD display two types of protein deposits: extracellular amyloid plaques and intracellular neurofibrillary tangles. The latter neuropathological change is also observed in a series of other neurological conditions that have been collectively named tauopathies and include some forms of Parkinsonism, Pick’s disease, and boxinginduced dementia (Dementia pugilistica). oligomeric state) and in protection from oxidative damage (DJ-1 protein), with mutations associated to PD. Summarizing, in cases with non-apparent familial genetic defects associated, along with an age-related tendency to accumulate oxidized damaged proteins, failure of the UPS to adequately remove misfolded/abnormal proteins may underlie the degeneration of nigral cells in sporadic disease. Proteolytic stress with an accompanying defect in protein handling is crucial and the substantia nigra neurons are particularly vulnerable due to their high content of dopamine. And this vulnerability is very likely due to the high basal rate of protein oxidation which is due to the enzymatic and autooxidative machineries involved in dopamine oxidation. The plaques in AD are rich in amyloid β peptides (Aβ) that are produced by proteolytic cleavage of the amyloid precursor peptide (APP), a glycolipid located in the outer cell membrane. Three different proteases, called α, β, and γ secretases, can cleave APP at specific sites. Concomitant cleavage of APP by β and γ secretase at specific sites can result in fragments that can misfold and form extracellular fibrils. These fibrils consist of β sheets. It is debated whether the fibrils are toxic through formation of pores or whether the extracellular amyloid deposits are the main culprits. The Aβ in plaques arises from specific
processing of app that is positively regulated age. The ability to increase ubiquitin by the presenilins ps1 and PS2 patients express mutant presenilin forms decreases in ageing tissue, The proteasome can change the processing of APp by altering Y activity in the mammalian brain decreases secretase activity, thereby promoting the with increasing age(Keller et al. 2002) generation of amyloidogenic AB suggesting that the aged brain is less able the The neurofibrillary tanglesare aberrantly folded AB. That doesn't exclude intracellular and are rich in tau a structural that simultaneous abnormally increased levels protein that is normally associated with of the peptide may start accumulating by microtubule. In conjunction with the formation additional reasons of neurofibrillary tangles, synthesis of the tau Perhaps the most compelling evidence for the protein increases, undergoing an abnormal nvolvement of the UPS in AD pathogenesis posttranslational modification characterized comes from the discovery that the mutant by hyperphosphorylation. lyt Ububiquitin form Ubhas been found not processing/degradation of tau is believed to only in neurons of patients with AD, Down be important for the formation of the syndrome (which develop AD-like brain neurofibrillary tangles. Mutations in the tau pathology when middle-aged) but also in brains gene can cause the tauopathy Picks disease of elderly patients with mild cognitive but mutant tau alone does not c AD mpairment (without any other known favoring that accumulation of erroneously predisposing factors) and with other processed Ap a key event in AD pathogene neurodegenerative disease. A transcriptional misreading can cause the deletion of two nucleotides in the mrNa Familial cases of ad with an autosomal- coding for ubiquitin, which causes the dominant inheritance constitute only 5% of the replacement of the C-terminal residue of cases but as with PD studies, they have been Ub (G76) with a 20-residue(+1)extension structive in unraveling possible pathogenic (Ub). This mutant form cannot be attached mechanisms involved in the sporadic, aging- directly to protein substrates but wild-type related, cases. They have demonstrated tha ubiquitin simultaneously produced from AD can be caused by mutations in the App correctly generated transcripts can bind to its cmi ausing abnormal APP processing ,or intact internal lysines. When a mutant Ubis rise to a peptide that is more likely to attached this way to the last wild-type ubiquitin added to a polyubiq Several lines of evidence point to a reduced substrate no more ubiquitins can subsequently UPs function in AD and suggest that both AB be attached since Ub is missing the c and tau in their abnormal forms are terminal G76 important players in the pathogenesis of AD polyubiquitin chains cannot be deubiquitinated by ultimately causing inhibition of proteasome and their slow-rate accumulation ends up function causing a dominant-negative inhibition of the proteasome Does a reduction in the activity of the UPs Therefore, recent reports showing that Ub lead to a greater tendency AB to accumulate can inhibit the proteasome suggests that it and generate amyloid plaques, or do may contribute to the pathogenesis o conformational changes in AB or tau cause neurodegenerative diseases. proteasome inhibition? One characteristic of AD is that it shows a higher prevalence with
processing of APP that is positively regulated by the presenilins PS1 and PS2. Some patients express mutant presenilin forms that can change the processing of APP by altering γ secretase activity, thereby promoting the generation of amyloidogenic Aβ. The neurofibrillary tangles are intracellular and are rich in tau, a structural protein that is normally associated with microtubuli. In conjunction with the formation of neurofibrillary tangles, synthesis of the tau protein increases, undergoing an abnormal posttranslational modification characterized by hyperphosphorylation. Proteolytic processing/degradation of tau is believed to be important for the formation of the neurofibrillary tangles. Mutations in the tau gene can cause the tauopathy Pick’s disease but mutant tau alone does not cause AD, favoring that accumulation of erroneously processed Aβ a key event in AD pathogenesis. Familial cases of AD with an autosomaldominant inheritance constitute only 5% of the cases but as with PD studies, they have been instructive in unraveling possible pathogenic mechanisms involved in the sporadic, agingrelated, cases. They have demonstrated that AD can be caused by mutations in the APP gene, causing abnormal APP processing, or giving rise to a peptide that is more likely to self-aggregate. Several lines of evidence point to a reduced UPS function in AD and suggest that both Aβ and tau in their abnormal forms are important players in the pathogenesis of AD by ultimately causing inhibition of proteasome function. Does a reduction in the activity of the UPS lead to a greater tendency Aβ to accumulate and generate amyloid plaques, or do conformational changes in Aβ or tau cause proteasome inhibition? One characteristic of AD is that it shows a higher prevalence with age. The ability to increase ubiquitin conjugation in response to stressors decreases in ageing tissue. The proteasome activity in the mammalian brain decreases with increasing age (Keller et al., 2002), suggesting that the aged brain is less able the aberrantly folded Aβ. That doesn’t exclude that simultaneous abnormally increased levels of the peptide may start accumulating by additional reasons. Perhaps the most compelling evidence for the involvement of the UPS in AD pathogenesis comes from the discovery that the mutant Ub+1 ubiquitin form. Ub+1 has been found not only in neurons of patients with AD, Down’s syndrome (which develop AD-like brain pathology when middle-aged) but also in brains of elderly patients with mild cognitive impairment (without any other known predisposing factors) and with other neurodegenerative disease. A transcriptional misreading can cause the deletion of two nucleotides in the mRNA coding for ubiquitin, which causes the replacement of the C-terminal residue of Ub (G76) with a 20-residue (+1) extension (Ub+1). This mutant form cannot be attached directly to protein substrates but wild-type ubiquitin simultaneously produced from correctly generated transcripts can bind to its intact internal lysines. When a mutant Ub+1 is attached this way to the last wild-type ubiquitin added to a polyubiquitin chain in a substrate no more ubiquitins can subsequently be attached since Ub+1 is missing the Cterminal G76. These Ub+1-capped polyubiquitin chains cannot be deubiquitinated and their slow-rate accumulation ends up causing a “dominant-negative” inhibition of the proteasome. Therefore, recent reports showing that Ub+1 can inhibit the proteasome suggests that it may contribute to the pathogenesis of neurodegenerative diseases