COMPOSITES SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY ELSEVIER Composites Science and Technology 61(2001)1331-1338 www.elsevier.com/locate/compsci Notch sensitivity of fatigue life in a Sylramic M/Sic composite at elevated temperature J.C. McNulty, M.Y. He, F W. Zok Materials Department, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, US.A Received 16 March 2000: received in revised form 20 February 2001; accepted 7 March 2001 The effects of holes and notches on the fatigue life of an advanced SylramicTM/SiC composite at 815.C have been examined.At this temperature, fracture occurs by an oxidative embrittlement mechanism, common to most Sic-based composites In unnotched specimens, embrittlement is manifested at stresses above the matrix cracking limit, omc, leading to fracture following relatively short exposure times(100 h). As a consequence, a fatigue threshold is obtained at a stress, oth a Ome. This threshold is due to the absence of an easy path for oxygen ingress when matrix cracks are not present. In center-hole specimens, an analogous threshold is btained at a stress, oth S Omc/ke, where ke is the elastic stress concentration factor(=2.5). That is, once the cracking limit is exceeded at the hole edge, embrittlement and fracture ensue. The threshold stress for center-notch specimens with stress con- centration ke 7 is numerically similar to that of the center-hole specimens with ke 2.5, indicating some tolerance to local stress levels above the global matrix cracking limit in sharply notched geometries. Non-linear finite-element calculations of the stresses in the center-hole and center-notch specimens are used to infer the local conditions associated with the threshold a key result is that the damage tolerance and notch insensitivity normally associated with inelastic straining cannot be exploited at temperatures at which the embrittlement mechanism operates. The implication is that composite structures with holes and notches must be designed extremely conservatively to ensure long lifetimes(>100 h).@ 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved Keywords: Notch sensitivity; Fatigue; SiC composite; Embrittlement 1. Introduction based CFCCs exhibit inelastic deformation associated with matrix cracking and interface debonding, provid Continuous-fiber ceramic composites(CFCCs)based ing damage tolerance and strength retention in the pre- on SiC constituents have been under development for sence of holes and notches [3-5] the past two decades, mainly for use in advanced gas The most significant problem hindering SiC--CFCCs is turbine engines. The motivation for this activity is the oxidation embrittlement. The embrittlement most com- desire to increase operating temperatures and hence monly occurs by oxygen ingress through matrix cracks improve engine efficiency and performance. Additional followed by reaction of the oxygen with the fibers and the benefits associated with the elimination of film cooling fiber coatings [6-22]. The problem is particularly severe of combustor liners and the ensuing reductions in No at intermediate temperatures(500-900oC)[6, 15, 23-34] emissions have also been identified [1, 2 It is expected to be exacerbated by cyclic loading, since The selection of Sic as the main constituent in high- under such conditions the reaction gases contained performance CFCCs is based on a number of attractive within the crack are expelled during unloading and the physical and mechanical characteristics. Notably, their oxidizing atmosphere drawn into the composite through ow diffusivity results in good creep resistance at high matrix cracks during reloading. Cyclic loading may also temperatures. Furthermore, their high thermal con- accelerate fiber fracture in regions where the fibers have ductivity and low thermal expansion coefficient lead to bonded to the surrounding matrix as a consequence of high thermal shock resistance. In addition, the Sic- the oxidation process, thereby limiting the extent of further sliding along the fiber/matrix interface Corresponding author. Tel: +1-805-893-8699: fax: 1-805-893 The present paper examines the embrittlement phe- nomenon in an advanced Sic-CFCC which is currently E-imail address: zok(@engineering. ucsb. edu(F w. Zok) of interest to both the aerospace and the land-base 0266-3538/01/ S.see front matter C 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. PII:S0266-3538(01)00032-X
Notch sensitivity of fatigue life in a Sylramic TM/SiC composite at elevated temperature J.C. McNulty, M.Y. He, F.W. Zok* Materials Department, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USA Received 16 March 2000; received in revised form 20 February 2001; accepted 7 March 2001 Abstract The effects of holes and notches on the fatigue life of an advanced SylramicTM/SiC composite at 815C have been examined. At this temperature, fracture occurs by an oxidative embrittlement mechanism, common to most SiC-based composites. In unnotched specimens, embrittlement is manifested at stresses above the matrix cracking limit, mc, leading to fracture following relatively short exposure times (100 h). As a consequence, a fatigue threshold is obtained at a stress, th mc. This threshold is due to the absence of an easy path for oxygen ingress when matrix cracks are not present. In center-hole specimens, an analogous threshold is obtained, at a stress, th mc=ke, where ke is the elastic stress concentration factor (= 2.5). That is, once the cracking limit is exceeded at the hole edge, embrittlement and fracture ensue. The threshold stress for center-notch specimens with stress concentration ke ¼ 7 is numerically similar to that of the center-hole specimens with ke ¼ 2:5, indicating some tolerance to local stress levels above the global matrix cracking limit in sharply notched geometries. Non-linear finite-element calculations of the stresses in the center-hole and center-notch specimens are used to infer the local conditions associated with the threshold. A key result is that the damage tolerance and notch insensitivity normally associated with inelastic straining cannot be exploited at temperatures at which the embrittlement mechanism operates. The implication is that composite structures with holes and notches must be designed extremely conservatively to ensure long lifetimes (> 100 h). # 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Notch sensitivity; Fatigue; SiC composite; Embrittlement 1. Introduction Continuous-fiber ceramic composites (CFCCs) based on SiC constituents have been under development for the past two decades, mainly for use in advanced gas turbine engines. The motivation for this activity is the desire to increase operating temperatures and hence improve engine efficiency and performance. Additional benefits associated with the elimination of film cooling of combustor liners and the ensuing reductions in NOx emissions have also been identified [1,2]. The selection of SiC as the main constituent in highperformance CFCCs is based on a number of attractive physical and mechanical characteristics. Notably, their low diffusivity results in good creep resistance at high temperatures. Furthermore, their high thermal conductivity and low thermal expansion coefficient lead to high thermal shock resistance. In addition, the SiCbased CFCCs exhibit inelastic deformation associated with matrix cracking and interface debonding, providing damage tolerance and strength retention in the presence of holes and notches [3–5]. The most significant problem hindering SiC–CFCCs is oxidation embrittlement. The embrittlement most commonly occurs by oxygen ingress through matrix cracks, followed by reaction of the oxygen with the fibers and the fiber coatings [6–22]. The problem is particularly severe at intermediate temperatures (500–900C) [6,15,23–34]. It is expected to be exacerbated by cyclic loading, since under such conditions the reaction gases contained within the crack are expelled during unloading and the oxidizing atmosphere drawn into the composite through matrix cracks during reloading. Cyclic loading may also accelerate fiber fracture in regions where the fibers have bonded to the surrounding matrix as a consequence of the oxidation process, thereby limiting the extent of further sliding along the fiber/matrix interface. The present paper examines the embrittlement phenomenon in an advanced SiC–CFCC which is currently of interest to both the aerospace and the land-base 0266-3538/01/$ - see front matter # 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. PII: S0266-3538(01)00032-X Composites Science and Technology 61 (2001) 1331–1338 www.elsevier.com/locate/compscitech * Corresponding author. Tel.: +1-805-893-8699; fax: +1-805-893- 8486. E-mail address: zok@engineering.ucsb.edu (F.W. Zok).
1332 J C. McNulty et al. /Composites Science and Technolog y 61(2001)1331-1338 power-generation industries. Experiments are performed to assess the fatigue performance at a moderately high temperature(815oC). This temperature falls in the regime in which embrittlement has been reported for other SiC based CFCCs, yet is also relevant to the service environ- ments in which CFCC components are expected to operate in turbine engine applications. The sensitivity of fatigue life to stress concentrations is probed through tests on specimens with circular holes and notches as well as straight(unnotched)specimens. The study of the effects of stress concentrations is motivated by the need, in some instances, to use through-holes for either attachment or cooling in engine components. In a broader context, it might also be used to infer the extent of degradation due to foreign impact damage, assuming at the simplest level ( that the damaged region is unable to sustain load and hence acts similarly to a hole or notch. Some additional insights into the local conditions required for embrittle- ment and fracture in the notched geometries are obtained through calculations of the stresses in the notched geo metries, by the use of a non-linear constitutive law appropriate to CFCS 2. Materials and experimental measurements All experiments were performed on a composite com prising SylramicTM SiC! fibers in a plain-weave archi tecture and a Sic matrix produced by a proprietary hybrid process involving chemical vapor infiltration(CVI) and reactive melt infiltration(MD). The microstructure of the (b) composite is shown in Fig. 1. The notable features include the presence of a uniform Bn coating on the fibers, an overcoat'of SiC around the fiber tows(produced by CVn) and a Sic-based two-phase matrix (produced by reactive MI). The matrix is essentially fully dense, with out the large pores that are invariably present in CFCCs made by CVI alone. The absence of pores in the matrix has two consequences. First, it increases the stress at the onset of matrix cracking relative to that of the cvi CFCCs containing pores. Secondly, it is expected to improve the thermal conductivity, especially in the dire tion transverse to the fibers The fiber volume fraction To assess the effects of stress concentrators on low cycle fatigue(LCF), three types of specimens were used: (i) standard dog-bone(unnotched) specimens; (ii) straight tensile specimens of width 2W=31.8 mm, with a center hole of diameter 2a=6.35 mm (a/w=0.2); and (ii) straight tensile specimens of width 2W=31. 8 mm, with a Fig. 1. Scanning electron micrographs of a cross-section through the omposite:(a) at low magnification, showing the longitudinal and center notch of length 2a=6.35 mm (a/W=0.2)and transverse fiber tows; (b)at higher magnifications, showing the melt notch root radius p A0.2 mm. The specimens were tow. The micrographs were taken in backscatter electron imaging infiltrated matrix surrounding a fiber tow, and (c) the interior of the prepared by electrodischarge machining. Four spe mens of each geometry were tested at a temperature of (BED mode, thereby revealing atomic number contrast. The coatings on the fibers are bN. The Sic within the tows was produced by chemical vapor infiltration process, prior to melt-infiltration of th Produced by Dow Corning. remainder of the matrix
power-generation industries. Experiments are performed to assess the fatigue performance at a moderately high temperature (815C). This temperature falls in the regime in which embrittlement has been reported for other SiCbased CFCCs, yet is also relevant to the service environments in which CFCC components are expected to operate in turbine engine applications. The sensitivity of fatigue life to stress concentrations is probed through tests on specimens with circular holes and notches as well as straight (unnotched) specimens. The study of the effects of stress concentrations is motivated by the need, in some instances, to use through-holes for either attachment or cooling in engine components. In a broader context, it might also be used to infer the extent of degradation due to foreign impact damage, assuming at the simplest level that the damaged region is unable to sustain load and hence acts similarly to a hole or notch. Some additional insights into the local conditions required for embrittlement and fracture in the notched geometries are obtained through calculations of the stresses in the notched geometries, by the use of a non-linear constitutive law appropriate to CFCCs. 2. Materials and experimental measurements All experiments were performed on a composite comprising SylramicTM SiC1 fibers in a plain-weave architecture and a SiC matrix produced by a proprietary hybrid process involving chemical vapor infiltration (CVI) and reactive melt infiltration (MI). The microstructure of the composite is shown in Fig. 1. The notable features include the presence of a uniform BN coating on the fibers, an ‘overcoat’ of SiC around the fiber tows (produced by CVI) and a SiC-based two-phase matrix (produced by reactive MI). The matrix is essentially fully dense, without the large pores that are invariably present in CFCCs made by CVI alone. The absence of pores in the matrix has two consequences. First, it increases the stress at the onset of matrix cracking relative to that of the CVI CFCCs containing pores. Secondly, it is expected to improve the thermal conductivity, especially in the direction transverse to the fibers. The fiber volume fraction is 35%. To assess the effects of stress concentrators on low cycle fatigue (LCF), three types of specimens were used: (i) standard dog-bone (unnotched) specimens; (ii) straight tensile specimens of width 2W=31.8 mm, with a center hole of diameter 2a=6.35 mm ð Þ a=W ¼ 0:2 ; and (iii) straight tensile specimens of width 2W=31.8 mm, with a center notch of length 2a=6.35 mm ð Þ a=W ¼ 0:2 and notch root radius 0:2 mm. The specimens were prepared by electrodischarge machining. Four specimens of each geometry were tested at a temperature of 1 Produced by Dow Corning. Fig. 1. Scanning electron micrographs of a cross-section through the composite: (a) at low magnification, showing the longitudinal and transverse fiber tows; (b) at higher magnifications, showing the meltinfiltrated matrix surrounding a fiber tow, and (c) the interior of the tow. The micrographs were taken in backscatter electron imaging (BEI) mode, thereby revealing atomic number contrast. The coatings on the fibers are BN. The SiC within the tows was produced by a chemical vapor infiltration process, prior to melt-infiltration of the remainder of the matrix. 1332 J.C. McNulty et al. / Composites Science andTechnology 61 (2001) 1331–1338
J C. McNulty et al. /Composites Science and Technolog y 61(2001)1331-1338 815C in ambient air. The specimens were heated using an at a stress of 150-165 MPa. There was no apparent effect induction heating system and a steel susceptor. Tempera- of temperature on this response, except that the fracture tures were measured using thermocouples at three loca- strain at 815C was slightly lower than that at 20C tions on the specimen surface: at the center and at points Optical microscopy of polished cross-sections through the located +20 mm from the center. The temperatures at fractured test specimens revealed periodic matrix cracks. these three locations were maintained within +5C of the as commonly observed in this class of CFCC. targeted temperature( 815oC)for the duration of each test The effects of holes on the net-section strength at Steel tabs were affixed to the specimen ends using a high room temperature are shown in Fig. 3. The strength temperature ceramic adhesive and the tabbed sections decreases with increasing hole size, to 70% of the then inserted into hydraulic wedge grips. Additionally, unnotched strength at 2a=6.3 mm. Similar reductions several tests were performed at room temperature on have been reported previously for SiC/SiC, SiC/MAS [5] straight (unnotched) specimens as well as center hole and all-oxide ceramic composites [35]. These effects can ecimens with hole diameters of either 2a=3. 18 or 6.35 be rationalized on the basis of the stress redistribution mm and with a/w=0.2. The latter tests were used to due to inelastic straining around the hole as well as the assess the extent of notch sensitivity under ambient size-scale dependence of the local conditions needed to conditions. These results formed the basis on which the precipitate fracture, as described in Section 4 notch sensitivity of lCF life was subseq uently assessed The LCF behavior of 815C is shown in Fig. 4. Several The elevated temperature tests included one mono- notable features emerge. (i) The monotonic tension tests tonic tension test on each specimen type at a stressing on the center-hole and center-notch geometries yield rate of do/dt= 100 MPa/min, typically leading to frac- strengths similar to one another, oc 160-165 MPa, Ire in <3 min. The remaining three specimens were subject to LCF tests with a stress ratio of R=0.o1. The ading spectrum comprised relatively rapid loading and unloading(each taking a I min), and a hold time of 2 h at the peak stress. This spectrum was chosen to simulate he loading conditions that a gas turbine engine compo- nent might encounter in service. The peak stress levels were selected on the basis of the monotonic tensile test results. In cases in which fracture did not occur. the test were terminated after I week( 160-170 h)of loading The room temperature tests were also performed at a stressing rate of 100 MPa/min redictions(d=0.75 mm) The monotonic tensile test results on the unnotched pecimens are plotted in Fig. 2. At both 20 and 815C, the tensile response is essentially bilinear, with the tran Hole Diameter, 2a(mm) sition in slope occurring at the onset of matrix cracking Fig 3. Effects of center holes on room-temperature tensile strength The solid line represents the prediction of the point stress fracture model for a characteristic distance of d=0.75 ● Center hole 口 Center Notch 250 =254 GPa Center hole °° 2 0.0 Strain (%) g. 2. Tensile notched specimens at both 20 815C. Note the strong similarity in the stress-strain response at the wo test temperatures. t difference being the strains at which Fig 4. Summary of lCf life at 815C. Arrows pointing to the right fracture occurs. The solid lines represent a bilinear fit to the data, used indicate runout; arrows pointing to the left indicate test results for calibrating the nonlinear constitutive law obtained from monotonic tension tests
815C in ambient air. The specimens were heated using an induction heating system and a steel susceptor. Temperatures were measured using thermocouples at three locations on the specimen surface: at the center and at points located 20 mm from the center. The temperatures at these three locations were maintained within 5C of the targeted temperature (815C) for the duration of each test. Steel tabs were affixed to the specimen ends using a high temperature ceramic adhesive and the tabbed sections then inserted into hydraulic wedge grips. Additionally, several tests were performed at room temperature on straight (unnotched) specimens as well as center hole specimens with hole diameters of either 2a=3.18 or 6.35 mm and with a=W ¼ 0:2. The latter tests were used to assess the extent of notch sensitivity under ambient conditions. These results formed the basis on which the notch sensitivity of LCF life was subsequently assessed. The elevated temperature tests included one monotonic tension test on each specimen type at a stressing rate of d=dt ¼ 100 MPa/min, typically leading to fracture in 43 min. The remaining three specimens were subject to LCF tests with a stress ratio of R=0.01. The loading spectrum comprised relatively rapid loading and unloading (each taking 1 min), and a hold time of 2 h at the peak stress. This spectrum was chosen to simulate the loading conditions that a gas turbine engine component might encounter in service. The peak stress levels were selected on the basis of the monotonic tensile test results. In cases in which fracture did not occur, the tests were terminated after 1 week ( 160–170 h) of loading. The room temperature tests were also performed at a stressing rate of 100 MPa/min. The monotonic tensile test results on the unnotched specimens are plotted in Fig. 2. At both 20 and 815C, the tensile response is essentially bilinear, with the transition in slope occurring at the onset of matrix cracking at a stress of 150–165 MPa. There was no apparent effect of temperature on this response, except that the fracture strain at 815C was slightly lower than that at 20C. Optical microscopy of polished cross-sections through the fractured test specimens revealed periodic matrix cracks, as commonly observed in this class of CFCC. The effects of holes on the net-section strength at room temperature are shown in Fig. 3. The strength decreases with increasing hole size, to 70% of the unnotched strength at 2a=6.3 mm. Similar reductions have been reported previously for SiC/SiC, SiC/MAS [5] and all-oxide ceramic composites [35]. These effects can be rationalized on the basis of the stress redistribution due to inelastic straining around the hole as well as the size-scale dependence of the local conditions needed to precipitate fracture, as described in Section 4. The LCF behavior of 815C is shown in Fig. 4. Several notable features emerge. (i) The monotonic tension tests on the center-hole and center-notch geometries yield strengths similar to one another, c160–165 MPa, Fig. 2. Tensile response of unnotched specimens at both 20 and 815C. Note the strong similarity in the stress-strain response at the two test temperatures, the key difference being the strains at which fracture occurs. The solid lines represent a bilinear fit to the data, used for calibrating the nonlinear constitutive law. Fig. 3. Effects of center holes on room-temperature tensile strength. The solid line represents the prediction of the point stress fracture model for a characteristic distance of d=0.75 mm. Fig. 4. Summary of LCF life at 815C. Arrows pointing to the right indicate runout; arrows pointing to the left indicate test results obtained from monotonic tension tests. J.C. McNulty et al. / Composites Science andTechnology 61 (2001) 1331–1338 1333
J.C. McNulty et al. /Composites Science and Technolog y 61(2001)1331-1338 despite large differences in the elastic stress concentration factors: ke=2.5 vs. 7. 1(see Appendix). These strengths are c60% of the unnotched monotonic strength, u N 270 MPa, measured at 815C. Evidently the degree of notch sensitivity at this temperature is only slightly greater than that at 25C.(ii) In the unnotched specimens, a fatigue threshold(defined by tr> 160h)was obtained at a stress level, oth N 165 MPa, corresponding closely to the matrix cracking limit: ome A 150-160 MPa(Fig. 2) relations between the threshold stress and the matrix cracking stress had been established previously for static loading of a CVI SiC/SiC at a temperature of 900C [31]. However, the cracking stress of the latter material was considerably lower(60-70 MPa), a consequence of the matrix porosity. (iii)In the center-hole and cen- 等0m ter-notch specimens, the threshold was considerably ower, oth N 60-85 MPa, representing 240-50% of the unnotched threshold. Essentially the same behavior was obtained with notches and holes. (iv) For all three spe- cimen geometries, the stress rupture curves were extre- mely shallow, with the exception of the regime at very short fracture times (r<<I h). Evidently fracture occurs very rapidly at stresses above the threshold level. The implication is that life prediction at stresses above the threshold is likely to be exceedingly difficult Representative fractured test specimens were exam ined in a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Typical Fig. 5. Fracture surface of a center hole specimen tested under features are shown in Figs. 5 and 6 Specimens subjected monotonic tension at 815C to monotonic tensile loading at elevated temperature exhibited little fiber pullout(Fig. 5), suggesting a rela- 4. Modeling of notch sensitivity tively high interfacial strength. However, there was no indication of oxidation on the fracture surfaces follow- In light of the extremely shallow stress rupture curves, ng the short exposure times( 3 min) of these test the modelling activity focused predominantly on the pecimens. Similarly low levels of pullout were observed effects of notches and holes on the threshold stress levels on the fracture surfaces of specimens tested at room A secondary priority was the notch sensitivity of the emperature monotonic tensile strength at ambient temperature By contrast, the LCF specimens exposed to elevated temperature for many hours exhibited significant levels 4.I. Notch sensitivity of monotonic tensile strengt of oxidation on the fracture plane. Fig. 6 shows micro- graphs of a center-hole specimen, tested at a peak stress, The notch sensitivity of strength under ambient(non ap=85 MPa. The regions of the fracture surface near oxidizing) conditions is dictated by two factors: ()the the hole edge exhibited particularly severe oxidation, as extent to which inelastic straining mitigates the stress manifest by the presence of a glassy layer on the axial concentration at the notch tip, and (i) the dependence fiber tows. Similar features were also observed on the of the fracture condition on the stress gradients that center-notch specimens The inference from the presence exist ahead of the notch. The former effects can be cal- of the glassy layer on the fiber fracture surfaces is that culated by finite element methods using a non-linear the fibers are failing progressively, starting near the tip constitutive law appropriate to CFCCs In the present of the notch or hole(where the stress concentration is at study, the law developed by Genin and Hutchinson [36] a maximum) and proceeding through the remaining has been used for such calculations. This constitutive (unnotched) section of the material. This sequence is law is based on a phenomenological description of the consistent with that observed in other SiC-based development of inelastic strain in cross-ply CFCCs CFCCS, as detailed in [15] under biaxial stressing. The pertinent functions are
despite large differences in the elastic stress concentration factors: ke=2.5 vs. 7.1 (see Appendix). These strengths are 60% of the unnotched monotonic strength, u 270 MPa, measured at 815C. Evidently the degree of notch sensitivity at this temperature is only slightly greater than that at 25C. (ii) In the unnotched specimens, a fatigue threshold (defined by tf5 160h) was obtained at a stress level, O th 165 MPa, corresponding closely to the matrix cracking limit: mc 150–160 MPa (Fig. 2). Similar correlations between the threshold stress and the matrix cracking stress had been established previously for static loading of a CVI SiC/SiC at a temperature of 900C [31]. However, the cracking stress of the latter material was considerably lower (60–70 MPa), a consequence of the matrix porosity. (iii) In the center-hole and center-notch specimens, the threshold was considerably lower, th 60–85 MPa, representing 40–50% of the unnotched threshold. Essentially the same behavior was obtained with notches and holes. (iv) For all three specimen geometries, the stress rupture curves were extremely shallow, with the exception of the regime at very short fracture times (tf<<1 h). Evidently fracture occurs very rapidly at stresses above the threshold level. The implication is that life prediction at stresses above the threshold is likely to be exceedingly difficult. 3. Fractography Representative fractured test specimens were examined in a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Typical features are shown in Figs. 5 and 6. Specimens subjected to monotonic tensile loading at elevated temperature exhibited little fiber pullout (Fig. 5), suggesting a relatively high interfacial strength. However, there was no indication of oxidation on the fracture surfaces following the short exposure times ( 3 min) of these test specimens. Similarly low levels of pullout were observed on the fracture surfaces of specimens tested at room temperature. By contrast, the LCF specimens exposed to elevated temperature for many hours exhibited significant levels of oxidation on the fracture plane. Fig. 6 shows micrographs of a center-hole specimen, tested at a peak stress, p ¼85 MPa. The regions of the fracture surface near the hole edge exhibited particularly severe oxidation, as manifest by the presence of a glassy layer on the axial fiber tows. Similar features were also observed on the center-notch specimens. The inference from the presence of the glassy layer on the fiber fracture surfaces is that the fibers are failing progressively, starting near the tip of the notch or hole (where the stress concentration is at a maximum) and proceeding through the remaining (unnotched) section of the material. This sequence is consistent with that observed in other SiC-based CFCCs, as detailed in [15]. 4. Modeling of notch sensitivity In light of the extremely shallow stress rupture curves, the modelling activity focused predominantly on the effects of notches and holes on the threshold stress levels. A secondary priority was the notch sensitivity of the monotonic tensile strength at ambient temperature. 4.1. Notch sensitivity of monotonic tensile strength The notch sensitivity of strength under ambient (nonoxidizing) conditions is dictated by two factors: (i) the extent to which inelastic straining mitigates the stress concentration at the notch tip, and (ii) the dependence of the fracture condition on the stress gradients that exist ahead of the notch. The former effects can be calculated by finite element methods using a non-linear constitutive law appropriate to CFCCs. In the present study, the law developed by Genin and Hutchinson [36] has been used for such calculations. This constitutive law is based on a phenomenological description of the development of inelastic strain in cross-ply CFCCs under biaxial stressing. The pertinent functions are Fig. 5. Fracture surface of a center hole specimen tested under monotonic tension at 815C. 1334 J.C. McNulty et al. / Composites Science andTechnology 61 (2001) 1331–1338
J.C. McNulty et al. /Composites Science and Technolog y 61(2001)1331-1338 calibrated using the results of tensile tests performed both into account [5, 35]. Furthermore, previous studies have along one of the fiber axes(in the 00/90 orientation) and revealed that the characteristic distance inferred from at 45 to the fiber axes. The constitutive law is then the model and the experiment is rather insensitive to the implemented in a finite-element code for the purpose of details of the composite microstructure, falling in the calculating stress and strain fields in non-uniform spe narrow range of 0.5-0.75 mm for SiC/SiC [5], SiC/ men or component geometries. The capability of the MAs [5] and an all-oxide CFCC [35] model to predict the latter response has been validated This approach has been used to model the strength of through comparisons with strain measurements on spe- the center-hole specimens of the SylramicM/SiC com- cimens containing notches and circular holes [5, 35]. The posite tested at room temperature, using a characteristic model tacitly assumes that the material response is distance, d=0. 75 mm. The effects of inelastic straining on scale-independent. This presents some limitations on the the stress distribution ahead of a hole are illustrated by the size-scale of features that can be accurately simulated, as results plotted in Fig. 7(a). The strength predictions are discussed in Section 4.2. Additional details of the imple- plotted in Fig 3, for comparison with the experimental mentation and calibration procedures are described in measurements. Excellent agreement between experiment Refs. [36] and [5] and theory is obtained. Furthermore, the inferred char- he effects of stress gradients on fracture are less well acteristic distance is remarkably similar to the values nderstood. Nevertheless, a simple fracture criterion obtained in other CFCCs, indicating a commonalty in based on the attainment of a critical stress( taken as the the factors controlling fracture of the various composite unnotched strength)over a characteristic distance d along systems the incipient fracture plane has been found to adequately The same approach has been used to rationalize the describe notched strength of CFCCs, provided the effects effects of both notches and holes on the strength at 815oC. of inelastic straining on the stress distribution are taken In this case, the characteristic distance was inferred 2.0 g =75 MPa 150M g15 0.10 Distance from hole edge, X/(W-a) m tch length, 2a=6. 35 mm EM model predictions 00002 0060.080.10 Fig. 7. Typical stress distributions for(a) center-hole and(b)center- 10m notched specimens of the SylramicTM/SiC composite, calculated using the nonlinear constitutive law of Genin and Hutchinson [36]. Also shown for comparison are the corresponding elastic predictions. The Fig. 6. Fracture surface of a center hole specimen tested in fatigue at results demonstrate the role of inelastic straining in mitigating stress ap=85 MPa at8l5°C
calibrated using the results of tensile tests performed both along one of the fiber axes (in the 0/90 orientation) and at 45 to the fiber axes. The constitutive law is then implemented in a finite-element code for the purpose of calculating stress and strain fields in non-uniform specimen or component geometries. The capability of the model to predict the latter response has been validated through comparisons with strain measurements on specimens containing notches and circular holes [5,35]. The model tacitly assumes that the material response is scale-independent. This presents some limitations on the size-scale of features that can be accurately simulated, as discussed in Section 4.2. Additional details of the implementation and calibration procedures are described in Refs. [36] and [5]. The effects of stress gradients on fracture are less well understood. Nevertheless, a simple fracture criterion based on the attainment of a critical stress (taken as the unnotched strength) over a characteristic distance d along the incipient fracture plane has been found to adequately describe notched strength of CFCCs, provided the effects of inelastic straining on the stress distribution are taken into account [5,35]. Furthermore, previous studies have revealed that the characteristic distance inferred from the model and the experiment is rather insensitive to the details of the composite microstructure, falling in the narrow range of 0.5–0.75 mm for SiC/SiC [5], SiC/ MAS [5] and an all-oxide CFCC [35]. This approach has been used to model the strength of the center-hole specimens of the SylramicTM/SiC composite tested at room temperature, using a characteristic distance, d=0.75 mm. The effects of inelastic straining on the stress distribution ahead of a hole are illustrated by the results plotted in Fig. 7(a). The strength predictions are plotted in Fig. 3, for comparison with the experimental measurements. Excellent agreement between experiment and theory is obtained. Furthermore, the inferred characteristic distance is remarkably similar to the values obtained in other CFCCs, indicating a commonalty in the factors controlling fracture of the various composite systems. The same approach has been used to rationalize the effects of both notches and holes on the strength at 815C. In this case, the characteristic distance was inferred Fig. 6. Fracture surface of a center hole specimen tested in fatigue at p ¼ 85 MPa at 815C. Fig. 7. Typical stress distributions for (a) center-hole and (b) centernotched specimens of the SylramicTM/SiC composite, calculated using the nonlinear constitutive law of Genin and Hutchinson [36]. Also shown for comparison are the corresponding elastic predictions. The results demonstrate the role of inelastic straining in mitigating stress concentrations. J.C. McNulty et al. / Composites Science andTechnology 61 (2001) 1331–1338 1335