Materials P rocessing Technology ELSEVIER of Materials Processing Technology 16 Processing and characterisation of model optomechanical composites in the system sapphire fibre/borosilicate glass matrix A.R. Boccaccini a,*. D. Acevedo a,A F. Dericioglu. C. Jana b National Institute for Materials Science, 1-2-1 Sengen, Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki 305-0047, Japan eSchott-Jenaer Glas GmbH. Otto Schott StraBe 13. D-07745 Jena germany Received 8 July 2004; accepted 11 March 2005 Abstract Optomechanical composites based on the system sapphire fibre/borosilicate glass matrix were fabricated and characterised. Different techniques of fabrication were used: composites with randomly orientated chopped sapphire fibres were produced by powder technology and pressureless sintering, whilst unidirectionally oriented fibre composites were fabricated by hot-pressing as well as by sandwiching glass slides and arrays of parallel fibres followed by heat-treatment. Pressureless sintered samples were poorly densified and were opaque. Hot-pressed and"sandwich structure"composites were dense and exhibited strong interfaces between fibres and matrix. Only the "sandwich structure composites were transparent and showed significant light transmittance in the visible wavelength range, only 20% lower than that of the unreinforced matrix. Due to the strong matrix/fibre interface limited fibre pull-out during composite fracture was observed. The fabricate B nsparent composites represent an improved version of the traditional material wired glass. They are candidate materials for applications in igh performance fire and impact resistant windows requiring high impact strength and avoidance of fragmentation upon fracture O 2005 Elsevier B. V. All rights reserved Keywords: Composite materials; Glass matrix; Hot-pressing; Sintering: Ceramic fibres; Mechanical properties; Optical properties 1. Introduction been carried out to understand the toughening mechanisms induced by the presence of the reinforcements and to inves- Silicate glasses have extremely low fracture toughness val- tigate the parameters that lead to satisfactory mechanical ues,which leads to the well known low reliability of these behaviour of glass and glass-ceramic matrix composites materials in load-bearing applications. Hence, strengthening [5-l1l and toughening of silicate glasses are required if these mate Limited previous research has been carried out focusing on rials are to find wider use in structural applications [1] improving simultaneously mechanical and functional prop- Forming composites by incorporation of reinforcing ele- erties of glass matrix composites. These include composites ments in glass and glass-ceramic matrices is a very effective for electric and electronic applications(e.g. induction heat approach to improve the mechanical properties of glasses, ing equipment, microwave components, electronic package including fracture strength, fracture toughness as well as substrates, connectors), high-temperature applications(e.g thermal shock and impact resistance Reinforcements thermal insulators, jet engine thermocouples), dimensional most commonly used are in the form of ceramic whiskers, stability applications(e.g. mirror supports for telescopes )and platelets, particulates or fibres [2-5]. Numerous studies have optical applications(e. g. impact resistant windows, struc ures for micro fluidics)[4, 12-20]. In particular, compos ding author. Tel 075946731;fax:+442075843194 ites exhibiting favourable optical and mechanical properties E-mail address: a boccaccini @imperial ac uk(A R. Boccaccini) are called <optomechanical composites>[ 18], which are the ss: GEMPPM de lyon,69621 Villeurbanne, France. focus of the present work 0924-0136/S- see front matter O 2005 Elsevier B V. All rights reserved doi: 10. 1016/j- imatprotec. 2005.03.011
Journal of Materials Processing Technology 169 (2005) 270–280 Processing and characterisation of model optomechanical composites in the system sapphire fibre/borosilicate glass matrix A.R. Boccaccini a,∗, D. Acevedo a,1, A.F. Dericioglu b, C. Jana c a Department of Materials, Imperial College London, Prince Consort Road, London SW7 2BP, UK b National Institute for Materials Science, 1-2-1 Sengen, Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki 305-0047, Japan c Schott-Jenaer Glas GmbH, Otto Schott Straße 13, D-07745 Jena, Germany Received 8 July 2004; accepted 11 March 2005 Abstract Optomechanical composites based on the system sapphire fibre/borosilicate glass matrix were fabricated and characterised. Different techniques of fabrication were used: composites with randomly orientated chopped sapphire fibres were produced by powder technology and pressureless sintering, whilst unidirectionally oriented fibre composites were fabricated by hot-pressing as well as by sandwiching glass slides and arrays of parallel fibres followed by heat-treatment. Pressureless sintered samples were poorly densified and were opaque. Hot-pressed and “sandwich structure” composites were dense and exhibited strong interfaces between fibres and matrix. Only the “sandwich structure” composites were transparent and showed significant light transmittance in the visible wavelength range, only 20% lower than that of the unreinforced matrix. Due to the strong matrix/fibre interface limited fibre pull-out during composite fracture was observed. The fabricated transparent composites represent an improved version of the traditional material wired glass. They are candidate materials for applications in high performance fire and impact resistant windows requiring high impact strength and avoidance of fragmentation upon fracture. © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. Keywords: Composite materials; Glass matrix; Hot-pressing; Sintering; Ceramic fibres; Mechanical properties; Optical properties 1. Introduction Silicate glasses have extremely low fracture toughness values, which leads to the well known low reliability of these materials in load-bearing applications. Hence, strengthening and toughening of silicate glasses are required if these materials are to find wider use in structural applications [1]. Forming composites by incorporation of reinforcing elements in glass and glass-ceramic matrices is a very effective approach to improve the mechanical properties of glasses, including fracture strength, fracture toughness as well as thermal shock and impact resistance [2–5]. Reinforcements most commonly used are in the form of ceramic whiskers, platelets, particulates or fibres [2–5]. Numerous studies have ∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +44 207 594 6731; fax: +44 207 584 3194. E-mail address: a.boccaccini@imperial.ac.uk (A.R. Boccaccini). 1 Present address: GEMPPM, INSA de Lyon, 69621 Villeurbanne, France. been carried out to understand the toughening mechanisms induced by the presence of the reinforcements and to investigate the parameters that lead to satisfactory mechanical behaviour of glass and glass-ceramic matrix composites [5–11]. Limited previous research has been carried out focusing on improving simultaneously mechanical and functional properties of glass matrix composites. These include composites for electric and electronic applications (e.g. induction heating equipment, microwave components, electronic package substrates, connectors), high-temperature applications (e.g. thermal insulators, jet engine thermocouples), dimensional stability applications (e.g. mirror supports for telescopes) and optical applications (e.g. impact resistant windows, structures for micro fluidics) [4,12–20]. In particular, composites exhibiting favourable optical and mechanical properties are called «optomechanical composites» [18], which are the focus of the present work. 0924-0136/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2005.03.011
A.R. Boccaccini et al. Joumal of Materials Processing Technology 169(2005)270-280 The main difficulty in the development of optomechanical its high thermal capability as well as considerable corrosion composites is the requirement of being able to improve the and thermal shock resistance [25]. In fact, borosilicate glass mechanical and optical properties simultaneously [18-24]. has been widely used in the past as the matrix for SiC and Indeed, most glass matrix composite materials developed to carbon fibre reinforced composites for structural application date are not optically transparent, or even translucent, because [4, 26]. Moreover, borosilicate glass matrices reinforced by of the type of reinforcements used(e.g. SiC or carbon fibres) a-Al2O3 in the form of particles, platelets and fibres have [2-5], and therefore, they cannot be considered to be suitable been the matter of numerous previous investigations due to materials for optomechanical applications. Hence, means of the favourable thermal expansion mismatch between alu- improving the mechanical properties of glasses without sig- mina and borosilicate glass composition [4, 6, 27]. Additional nificantly degrading their optical transparency need to be advantages of borosilicate glass are its optical propertie further investigated and relatively low dielectric constant [25, 28]. Sapphire The selection of appropriate fibres and matrices for fibres were selected because they exhibit outstanding high ptomechanical composites is a complex matter because temperature stability, high chemical durability and excellent numerous factors have to be considered. The main require- mechanical properties[29, 30]. Single crystal sapphire fibres ment for the fibres is that they should have a higher ther- have been used in previous studies to reinforce ceramic and mal stability than the glass matrix because of the usually glass matrices for high-temperature applications [30-331 high temperatures needed for matrix densification [18, 22]. In those studies however no special care was placed on Furthermore, matching the fibre and matrix thermal expan- the optical property(transparency)of composites, except sion coefficients is necessary in order to avoid large residual for some model systems fabricated for academic purposes stresses upon cooling from the fabrication temperature. How- [21]. Thus, to the authors'knowledge, this is the first work ever, the development of compressive residual stresses in the on the system sapphire fibre/borosilicate glass matrix with matrix by having fibres with thermal expansion coefficient the specific aim of producing transparent composites for higher than that of the matrix may be also favourable [ 18, 22]. optomechanical applications Finally, the strength of bonding at the interface between fibres and matrix is an important parameter since it has a large influ- ence on the mechanical behaviour of the final composites, as 2. Materials and experimental procedure it is the case in all brittle matrix composites [2-4]. In addi- tion to these requirements, matching of the fibre and matrix 2.1. Materials refractive indices is also necessary to avoid (or minimise) light scattering, and thus to obtain a transparent or at least Borosilicate glass was selected as the matrix material and 4]. Another possible option to it was used in two different forms: i) powder of mean particle obtain transparent composites is to include optical windows size <40 um(Duran", Schott Glas, Mainz, Germany)and ii) by a relatively large spacing of the reinforcing fibres in the glass plates of thickness 1. 1 mm(Borofloat33, Schott Jenaer matrix[18], in a similar way as in the traditional material Glas, Jena, Germany ) The properties of the glass are summa- wired glass. Recently, we have fabricated oxide-fibre rein- rized in Table 1[34]. The chemical composition of Duran forced glass matrix composites with high light transmittance glass is(in wt%)[34]: 81SiO2, 13B203, 4(Na20+K2O) (only 30% lower than that of the matrix)using the"optical 2Al2O3, which can be considered to be identical to that of windowconcept, which is based on the presence of relatively Borofloat33 large transparent matrix regions surrounded by the reinforc The reinforcement chosen was sapphire fibre of optical ing fibres [22]. Moreover, Dericiogluet al [18, 24] fabricated quality with nominal diameter 150 um(Saphikon",Laser minicomposite reinforced borosilicate glass matrix optome- Components UK, Ltd ) The fibres were received in length of chanical composites with low volume fraction of reinforce- I m and were cut manually to appropriate lengths for compos. ment exhibiting light transmittance higher than 80% of the ites fabrication by using metallic scissors. For all composites transmittance of the matrix, showing that even if the fibres fibres were used in the as-received condition. Sapphire fibres incorporated are opaque, it is possible to achieve considerable were selected because they exhibit outstanding thermome- optical transparency chanical properties [29-33]. This fibre is a monocrystal of A few experimental investigations aiming at producing a-Al2O3 of very high quality exhibiting high strength and optomechanical composites with technical applications have hardness. Additionally, because absence of grain boundaries been carried out, specially in Japan [17-20, 24, in Germany [15,16, 23] and in the UK [22], yet research in this field remains still rather limited. which has thus motivated the Properties of the borosilicate glass durAN[25, 34] present experimental study Density(gcm-3) The objective of this work is to explore and optimise dif- Tensile strength(MPa) 60 ferent methods to produce optically transparent borosilicate Elastic modulus(GPa) 64 glass matrix composites reinforced by single crystal Al2O Coefficient of thermal expansion(C) Refractive index 1.473 (sapphire)fibres. Borosilicate glass was chosen because of
A.R. Boccaccini et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 169 (2005) 270–280 271 The main difficulty in the development of optomechanical composites is the requirement of being able to improve the mechanical and optical properties simultaneously [18–24]. Indeed, most glass matrix composite materials developed to date are not optically transparent, or even translucent, because of the type of reinforcements used (e.g. SiC or carbon fibres) [2–5], and therefore, they cannot be considered to be suitable materials for optomechanical applications. Hence, means of improving the mechanical properties of glasses without significantly degrading their optical transparency need to be further investigated. The selection of appropriate fibres and matrices for optomechanical composites is a complex matter because numerous factors have to be considered. The main requirement for the fibres is that they should have a higher thermal stability than the glass matrix because of the usually high temperatures needed for matrix densification [18,22]. Furthermore, matching the fibre and matrix thermal expansion coefficients is necessary in order to avoid large residual stresses upon cooling from the fabrication temperature. However, the development of compressive residual stresses in the matrix by having fibres with thermal expansion coefficient higher than that of the matrix may be also favourable [18,22]. Finally, the strength of bonding at the interface between fibres and matrix is an important parameter since it has a large influence on the mechanical behaviour of the final composites, as it is the case in all brittle matrix composites [2–4]. In addition to these requirements, matching of the fibre and matrix refractive indices is also necessary to avoid (or minimise) light scattering, and thus to obtain a transparent or at least a translucent material [15–24]. Another possible option to obtain transparent composites is to include optical windows by a relatively large spacing of the reinforcing fibres in the matrix [18], in a similar way as in the traditional material wired glass. Recently, we have fabricated oxide-fibre reinforced glass matrix composites with high light transmittance (only 30% lower than that of the matrix) using the “optical window” concept, which is based on the presence of relatively large transparent matrix regions surrounded by the reinforcing fibres [22]. Moreover, Dericioglu et al. [18,24] fabricated minicomposite reinforced borosilicate glass matrix optomechanical composites with low volume fraction of reinforcement exhibiting light transmittance higher than 80% of the transmittance of the matrix, showing that even if the fibres incorporated are opaque, it is possible to achieve considerable optical transparency. A few experimental investigations aiming at producing optomechanical composites with technical applications have been carried out, specially in Japan [17–20,24], in Germany [15,16,23] and in the UK [22], yet research in this field remains still rather limited, which has thus motivated the present experimental study. The objective of this work is to explore and optimise different methods to produce optically transparent borosilicate glass matrix composites reinforced by single crystal Al2O3 (sapphire) fibres. Borosilicate glass was chosen because of its high thermal capability as well as considerable corrosion and thermal shock resistance [25]. In fact, borosilicate glass has been widely used in the past as the matrix for SiC and carbon fibre reinforced composites for structural applications [4,26]. Moreover, borosilicate glass matrices reinforced by -Al2O3 in the form of particles, platelets and fibres have been the matter of numerous previous investigations due to the favourable thermal expansion mismatch between alumina and borosilicate glass composition [4,6,27]. Additional advantages of borosilicate glass are its optical properties and relatively low dielectric constant [25,28]. Sapphire fibres were selected because they exhibit outstanding high temperature stability, high chemical durability and excellent mechanical properties [29,30]. Single crystal sapphire fibres have been used in previous studies to reinforce ceramic and glass matrices for high-temperature applications [30–33]. In those studies however no special care was placed on the optical property (transparency) of composites, except for some model systems fabricated for academic purposes [21]. Thus, to the authors’ knowledge, this is the first work on the system sapphire fibre/borosilicate glass matrix with the specific aim of producing transparent composites for optomechanical applications. 2. Materials and experimental procedure 2.1. Materials Borosilicate glass was selected as the matrix material and it was used in two different forms: i) powder of mean particle size <40m (Duran®, Schott Glas, Mainz, Germany) and ii) glass plates of thickness 1.1 mm (Borofloat® 33, Schott Jenaer Glas, Jena, Germany). The properties of the glass are summarized in Table 1 [34]. The chemical composition of Duran® glass is (in wt%) [34]: 81SiO2, 13B2O3, 4(Na2O+K2O), 2Al2O3, which can be considered to be identical to that of Borofloat® 33. The reinforcement chosen was sapphire fibre of optical quality with nominal diameter 150 m (Saphikon®, Laser Components UK, Ltd.). The fibres were received in length of 1 m and were cut manually to appropriate lengths for composites fabrication by using metallic scissors. For all composites, fibres were used in the as-received condition. Sapphire fibres were selected because they exhibit outstanding thermomechanical properties [29–33]. This fibre is a monocrystal of -Al2O3 of very high quality exhibiting high strength and hardness. Additionally, because absence of grain boundaries, Table 1 Properties of the borosilicate glass DURAN® [25,34] Density (g cm−3) 2.23 Tensile strength (MPa) 60 Elastic modulus (GPa) 64 Coefficient of thermal expansion (◦C−1) 3.3 × 10−6 Refractive index 1.473
272 A.R. Boccaccini er al. Joumal of Materials Processing Technology 169(2005)270-280 Table 2 erties of the Saphikon"fibres 35 Diameter(um) ~10mm Tensile strength(GPa) 2.1-3.4 Elastic modulus(GPa) 386-435 Melting point(°C) Coefficient of thermal expansion( K-) 79-8.8×10-6 Uniaxial refractive index 1.760-1.768 there is no light scattering within the sapphire fibres. Table 2 summarizes the main properties of the Saphikon"fibres used 351, and Fig. I shows a scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of the fibre. This micrograph confirms that the fibres ive a circular cross-section. moreover. it shows that Fig. 2. Arrangement of Saphikon fibres in(a) hot-pressed and(b)"sand- fibres have a very smooth surface, which will influence the wich structure"composites, in a volume fraction of approximately 5% possible toughening mechanisms acting in the composites a smooth interface should lead to greater average pull-out platelet reinforced glass matrix composites where the same lengths, and thus to higher fracture toughness provided there borosilicate glass matrix was used [37] is optimal bonding strength between the fibre and the matrix [36] 2.2.2. Hot-pressing A custom-made vacuum hot-press described in previous 2.2. Preparation of the composites works [38 was used. Samples made of pure glass matrix and fibre reinforced composites were fabricated. The average 2.2 Pressureless sintering fibre length was about 10 mm. The fibres were arranged par A mixture of borosilicate glass powder and 5% in volume allel to each other on a slightly pressed thin layer of powder of chopped sapphire fibres with a length of - l mm was pre- in a carbon die. They were separated an average distance of pared. Fibres were cut using scissors to the required length, I mm, as shown in Fig. 2(a). Subsequently, a second layer and matrix powder and fibres were mixed in dry conditions of powder was added above the fibres and the composites in a rotary mixer for Ih were hot-pressed The mixture was pressed into cylindrical samples of 8mm The volume fraction of fibres in the rectangular samples diameter in a die at room temperature by application of a which were cut out of the hot-pressed disc, as shown in ompacting pressure of about 100 MPa for 2 min No binder Fig. 2(a), was approximately 5%. The parameters used for was used in this operation. The pellets were then sintered in the fabrication of the samples were heating rate 100.Ch-I an electric furnace at 750"C for 2h in normal atmosphere. holding temperature 750 C, holding time I h, applied pres- to cool down in the furnace. The sintering temperature was chosen on the basis of previous investigations on alumina 2.2.3. "Sandwich structure"method This is a simple pressureless method for composite fab- rication introduced recently [22]. The method consists of sandwiching the reinforcing fibres between two glass plates, as shown in Fig. 2(b), and then subjecting the"sandwich structure to a heat treatment to consolidate the composite by exploiting viscous flow of the glass. The as-received plates of borosilicate glass( Borofloat 33)were cut by means ofa dia- mond tip to the desired dimensions(about 2.5 cm x 1. 5 cm) The average length of the fibres was 8 mm. The same dispo- sition as in the hot-pressed samples was used: fibres wer arranged parallel to each other, and the average distance between two fibres was about I mm(see Fig. 2(b)) he heat-treatment consisted of two main steps. In the ⊙AQ1991sEI first step, the glass plates were heated under a high vacuum to clean the surface by degassing. Subsequently, the sandwich structure was subjected to a second heat-treatment. The heat- Fig. 1. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of a Saphikon" fibre ing rate was 100oCh-, the holding temperature was varied used in the present work. between 750 and 775 C the holding time was between 2.5
272 A.R. Boccaccini et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 169 (2005) 270–280 Table 2 Properties of the Saphikon® fibres [35] Density (g cm−3) 3.99 Diameter (m) 150 Tensile strength (GPa) 2.1–3.4 Elastic modulus (GPa) 386–435 Melting point (◦C) 2053 Coefficient of thermal expansion (K−1) 7.9–8.8 × 10−6 Uniaxial refractive index 1.760–1.768 there is no light scattering within the sapphire fibres. Table 2 summarizes the main properties of the Saphikon® fibres used [35], and Fig. 1 shows a scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of the fibre. This micrograph confirms that the fibres have a circular cross-section. Moreover, it shows that the fibres have a very smooth surface, which will influence the possible toughening mechanisms acting in the composites: a smooth interface should lead to greater average pull-out lengths, and thus to higher fracture toughness provided there is optimal bonding strength between the fibre and the matrix [36]. 2.2. Preparation of the composites 2.2.1. Pressureless sintering A mixture of borosilicate glass powder and 5% in volume of chopped sapphire fibres with a length of ∼1 mm was prepared. Fibres were cut using scissors to the required length, and matrix powder and fibres were mixed in dry conditions in a rotary mixer for 1 h. The mixture was pressed into cylindrical samples of 8 mm diameter in a die at room temperature by application of a compacting pressure of about 100 MPa for 2 min. No binder was used in this operation. The pellets were then sintered in an electric furnace at 750 ◦C for 2 h in normal atmosphere. The heating rate used was 5 ◦C min−1. Samples were left to cool down in the furnace. The sintering temperature was chosen on the basis of previous investigations on alumina Fig. 1. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of a Saphikon® fibre used in the present work. Fig. 2. Arrangement of Saphikon® fibres in (a) hot-pressed and (b) “sandwich structure” composites, in a volume fraction of approximately 5%. platelet reinforced glass matrix composites where the same borosilicate glass matrix was used [37]. 2.2.2. Hot-pressing A custom-made vacuum hot-press described in previous works [38] was used. Samples made of pure glass matrix and fibre reinforced composites were fabricated. The average fibre length was about 10 mm. The fibres were arranged parallel to each other on a slightly pressed thin layer of powder in a carbon die. They were separated an average distance of ∼1 mm, as shown in Fig. 2(a). Subsequently, a second layer of powder was added above the fibres and the composites were hot-pressed. The volume fraction of fibres in the rectangular samples, which were cut out of the hot-pressed disc, as shown in Fig. 2(a), was approximately 5%. The parameters used for the fabrication of the samples were: heating rate 100 ◦C h−1, holding temperature 750 ◦C, holding time 1 h, applied pressure 10 MPa and cooling rate 100 ◦C min−1. 2.2.3. “Sandwich structure” method This is a simple pressureless method for composite fabrication introduced recently [22]. The method consists of sandwiching the reinforcing fibres between two glass plates, as shown in Fig. 2(b), and then subjecting the “sandwich structure” to a heat treatment to consolidate the composite by exploiting viscous flow of the glass. The as-received plates of borosilicate glass (Borofloat® 33) were cut by means of a diamond tip to the desired dimensions (about 2.5 cm × 1.5 cm). The average length of the fibres was 8 mm. The same disposition as in the hot-pressed samples was used: fibres were arranged parallel to each other, and the average distance between two fibres was about 1 mm (see Fig. 2(b)). The heat-treatment consisted of two main steps. In the first step, the glass plates were heated under a high vacuum to clean the surface by degassing. Subsequently, the sandwich structure was subjected to a second heat-treatment. The heating rate was 100 ◦C h−1, the holding temperature was varied between 750 and 775 ◦C, the holding time was between 2.5
A.R. Boccaccini et al. Joumal of Materials Processing Technology 169(2005)270-280 273 and 5h and the cooling rate was varied between 100 and 3. Results and discussion 260Ch-. The degassing step included two different treat ments. Firstly, the sample was under a normal atmosphere and 3.1. Microstructural characterisation after completion of half of the holding time, a high vacuum vas produced in order to clean all the impurities that might 3.1.1. Sintered composit have burnt. All samples were produced using the same heat Successful fabrication of fibre reinforced glass matrix ing and cooling rates(100Ch-l)in both steps, the holding composites relies on knowing the relationship between tem- temperature and holding time for the first step were 500oc perature and viscosity of the glass matrix. As it is well-known and 4 h, respectively, and they were 750C and 5 h for the for Duran-type borosilicate glass [34,371, the range of suit second step, respectively able temperatures for sintering glass powder is very narrow between720and780°C). A difference of±20° C in the sin- 2.3. Characterization techniques tering temperature can have a large effect on the densification The density of sintered and hot-pressed samples was deter- mined by the Archimedes'method. The relative density was gation were not translucent and their densification was not calculated by considering the theoretical density of the com- completely achieved; the sintered relative densities were in posites based on the density data for matrix and fibres, given the range 80-83% of theoretical density. Fig. 3(a-c)show in Tables 1 and 2, respectively, and the volume fraction of SEM micrographs of polished cross-sections of a chopped fibres. For microstructural characterisation, samples were fibre reinforced sintered composite at different magnifica cut,then mounted in resin and polished to 1 um finish with tions. Fig. 3(a)shows that the matrix close to the fibres is diamond paste to obtain flat cross sections for SEM. The porous and that larger defects are situated around the fibre, microstructures of selected sintered, hot-pressed and sand- confirming that it has not been possible to obtain a good wich structure samples were examined using conventional densification of the matrix in this region by pressureless sin- SEM(JEOL LV 5610)working in both secondary electron tering. The presence of randomly orientated fibres impedes and backscattered electron modes the perfect flow of the viscous glass during sintering and Sintered samples were analysed using X-ray diffraction causes a high porosity of the matrix in the region close to the (XRD) to detect any crystallisation of the matrix. Sam- fibres. On the contrary, the matrix far away from the fibres ples were crushed to a fine powder, and then analysed with (Fig 3(b ))exhibits high densification with few isolated pores a Philips PW1700 series automated powder diffractometer Fig. 3(c)is a high magnification image of the fibre/matrix using Cu Ka radiation at 40 k V-40 mA with a seconda interface showing that the lack of densification impedes the ono To gain preliminary understanding of the fracture interface behaviour of the composites and qualitative information The poor densification of the pressureless sintered sam about the interaction(bonding) between fibres and matrix ples achieved in the present work is in broad agreement with during the fracture process, fractures surfaces were also previous studies that showed that the presence of rigid inclu- observed by SEM. ions makes the densification of a glass matrix composite a A preliminary assessment of the optical quality of the sam- difficult task and that the density of the composites decreases ples was obtained by placing selected samples at different with increasing volume fraction of rigid inclusions [39-411 heights over a written text on a white surface and assessing Different explanations for this phenomenon have been pro- the text legibility. This qualitatively demonstrated the light posed. An inhomogeneous distribution of inclusions in the transmitting characteristics of the different composites. a powder can lead to a poor matrix particle packing and for digital camera was used to document this behaviour. Fab- mation of agglomerates, and thus the porosity will increase ricated"sandwich structure" composites were also observed around the fibres [39]. Moreover, studies conducted using the by means of a conventional optical microscope same materials but different mixing conditions have shown Light transmittance of the hot-pressed and"sandwich that optimised wet-mixing techniques lead to higher densities ructure"samples(with and without fibres) was measured at as they allow for more homogeneous mixtures[42]. Since the room temperature by a UV-visible spectrophotometer (UV- present glass powder/chopped fibres mixture was prepared in 1601 Shimadzu, Japan ), in the direction perpendicular dry conditions, the last explanation may be applicable to our the fibres axis. Before light transmittance measurements, results samples were cut and polished to obtain the size required Another factor affecting the densification of composites r the measurements. The thickness of the samples was containing rigid inclusions is the development of residual 2.3+0.1 mm, and the light transmittance was measured for stresses as a consequence of different sintering rates of matrix wavelengths between 350 and 800 nm. The light transmit- and inclusions. These stresses may cause sintering damage, ance of the samples was reported as a percentage of the leading to crack-like voids or isolated pores and conse- transmittance of a reference monolithic borosilicate gla quently to poor mechanical properties of the sintered samples slide(Borofloat 33) [39-42]
A.R. Boccaccini et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 169 (2005) 270–280 273 and 5 h and the cooling rate was varied between 100 and 260 ◦C h−1. The degassing step included two different treatments. Firstly, the sample was under a normal atmosphere and after completion of half of the holding time, a high vacuum was produced in order to clean all the impurities that might have burnt. All samples were produced using the same heating and cooling rates (100 ◦C h−1) in both steps, the holding temperature and holding time for the first step were 500 ◦C and 4 h, respectively, and they were 750 ◦C and 5 h for the second step, respectively. 2.3. Characterization techniques The density of sintered and hot-pressed samples was determined by the Archimedes’ method. The relative density was calculated by considering the theoretical density of the composites based on the density data for matrix and fibres, given in Tables 1 and 2, respectively, and the volume fraction of fibres. For microstructural characterisation, samples were cut, then mounted in resin and polished to 1 m finish with diamond paste to obtain flat cross sections for SEM. The microstructures of selected sintered, hot-pressed and sandwich structure samples were examined using conventional SEM (JEOL LV 5610) working in both secondary electron and backscattered electron modes. Sintered samples were analysed using X-ray diffraction (XRD) to detect any crystallisation of the matrix. Samples were crushed to a fine powder, and then analysed with a Philips PW1700 series automated powder diffractometer using Cu K radiation at 40 kV–40 mA with a secondary crystal monochromator. To gain preliminary understanding of the fracture behaviour of the composites and qualitative information about the interaction (bonding) between fibres and matrix during the fracture process, fractures surfaces were also observed by SEM. A preliminary assessment of the optical quality of the samples was obtained by placing selected samples at different heights over a written text on a white surface and assessing the text legibility. This qualitatively demonstrated the light transmitting characteristics of the different composites. A digital camera was used to document this behaviour. Fabricated “sandwich structure” composites were also observed by means of a conventional optical microscope. Light transmittance of the hot-pressed and “sandwich structure” samples (with and without fibres) was measured at room temperature by a UV–visible spectrophotometer (UV- 1601 Shimadzu, Japan), in the direction perpendicular to the fibres axis. Before light transmittance measurements, samples were cut and polished to obtain the size required for the measurements. The thickness of the samples was 2.3 ± 0.1 mm, and the light transmittance was measured for wavelengths between 350 and 800 nm. The light transmittance of the samples was reported as a percentage of the transmittance of a reference monolithic borosilicate glass slide (Borofloat® 33). 3. Results and discussion 3.1. Microstructural characterisation 3.1.1. Sintered composites Successful fabrication of fibre reinforced glass matrix composites relies on knowing the relationship between temperature and viscosity of the glass matrix. As it is well-known for Duran®-type borosilicate glass [34,37], the range of suitable temperatures for sintering glass powder is very narrow (between 720 and 780 ◦C). A difference of ±20 ◦C in the sintering temperature can have a large effect on the densification of the composites. Pressureless sintered samples fabricated in this investigation were not translucent and their densification was not completely achieved; the sintered relative densities were in the range 80–83% of theoretical density. Fig. 3(a–c) show SEM micrographs of polished cross-sections of a chopped fibre reinforced sintered composite at different magnifications. Fig. 3(a) shows that the matrix close to the fibres is porous and that larger defects are situated around the fibre, confirming that it has not been possible to obtain a good densification of the matrix in this region by pressureless sintering. The presence of randomly orientated fibres impedes the perfect flow of the viscous glass during sintering and causes a high porosity of the matrix in the region close to the fibres. On the contrary, the matrix far away from the fibres (Fig. 3(b)) exhibits high densification with few isolated pores. Fig. 3(c) is a high magnification image of the fibre/matrix interface showing that the lack of densification impedes the complete bonding of fibre and matrix leading to an imperfect interface. The poor densification of the pressureless sintered samples achieved in the present work is in broad agreement with previous studies that showed that the presence of rigid inclusions makes the densification of a glass matrix composite a difficult task and that the density of the composites decreases with increasing volume fraction of rigid inclusions [39–41]. Different explanations for this phenomenon have been proposed. An inhomogeneous distribution of inclusions in the powder can lead to a poor matrix particle packing and formation of agglomerates, and thus the porosity will increase around the fibres[39]. Moreover, studies conducted using the same materials but different mixing conditions have shown that optimised wet-mixing techniques lead to higher densities as they allow for more homogeneous mixtures[42]. Since the present glass powder/chopped fibres mixture was prepared in dry conditions, the last explanation may be applicable to our results. Another factor affecting the densification of composites containing rigid inclusions is the development of residual stresses as a consequence of different sintering rates of matrix and inclusions. These stresses may cause sintering damage, leading to crack-like voids or isolated pores and consequently to poor mechanical properties of the sintered samples [39–42].
A.R. Boccaccini et al. Joumal of Materials Processing Technology 169(2005)270-280 matrix Fig 3 SEM micrographs of Sapphire fibre rced pressureless sintered composites at different magnifications:(a) area around a fibre showing porosity and sintering defects, (b) matrix far away from the fibres exhibiting high densification and (c) high magnification image of the fibre/matrix interface showing mperfect bonding The existence of different"kinds" of porosity in the green lar result was obtained for hot-pressed samples. Indeed it has compact has been also proposed to explain the retardation of been proved in previous studies [27, 28, 43] that cristobalite densification in composites containing rigid inclusions [39]. crystallisation could happen in Al2O3/borosilicate glass com Pores can be embedded in the matrix material only, or they can posites with low volume fractions of Al2O3 (<10%)and even be located at the interface between matrix and inclusions. This when sintering temperature is low (in the range 700-800oC) is confirmed in the present composites by the micrographs analysed above( Fig 3(a and c)). It is observed that pores are situated both in the matrix and at the interface between matrix Counts/s and fibres. These different pore types in the initial compact will have different free surface energies, and thus, they will lead to an overall lower driving force for sintering in the composite than in the inclusion-free compact [39] and thus to a less densified composite. However, Fig. 3(b)shows that far away from the fibres, the matrix was very well densified confirming that the parameters used for sintering(time and temperature)were appropriate for this glass Fig. 4 shows the XRD pattern for a Saphikonfibr reinforced sintered composite. The only crystalline phase detected was corundum, which corresponds to the crystalline of the Saphikon fibres used. No cristobalite has crystallised in the matrix, which is a favourable result from the Fig. 4. XRD patte Saphikon" fibre reinforced sintered composite showing corundum as the only cristalline phase, which corresponds to the point of view of the composite mechanical strength. A simi- structure of the Saphikonfibres
274 A.R. Boccaccini et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 169 (2005) 270–280 Fig. 3. SEM micrographs of Sapphire® fibre reinforced pressureless sintered composites at different magnifications: (a) area around a fibre showing porosity and sintering defects, (b) matrix far away from the fibres exhibiting high densification and (c) high magnification image of the fibre/matrix interface showing imperfect bonding. The existence of different “kinds” of porosity in the green compact has been also proposed to explain the retardation of densification in composites containing rigid inclusions [39]. Pores can be embedded in the matrix material only, or they can be located at the interface between matrix and inclusions. This is confirmed in the present composites by the micrographs analysed above (Fig. 3(a and c)). It is observed that pores are situated both in the matrix and at the interface between matrix and fibres. These different pore types in the initial compact will have different free surface energies, and thus, they will lead to an overall lower driving force for sintering in the composite than in the inclusion-free compact [39] and thus to a less densified composite. However, Fig. 3(b) shows that far away from the fibres, the matrix was very well densified, confirming that the parameters used for sintering (time and temperature) were appropriate for this glass. Fig. 4 shows the XRD pattern for a Saphikon® fibre reinforced sintered composite. The only crystalline phase detected was corundum, which corresponds to the crystalline structure of the Saphikon® fibres used. No cristobalite has crystallised in the matrix, which is a favourable result from the point of view of the composite mechanical strength. A similar result was obtained for hot-pressed samples. Indeed it has been proved in previous studies [27,28,43] that cristobalite crystallisation could happen in Al2O3/borosilicate glass composites with low volume fractions of Al2O3 (<10%) and even when sintering temperature is low (in the range 700–800 ◦C). Fig. 4. XRD pattern of a Saphikon® fibre reinforced sintered composite showing corundum as the only cristalline phase, which corresponds to the structure of the Saphikon® fibres