What makes good science? Important and significant Original and innovative Solid and rigorous Unique and unusual Novelty is essential 语不惊人誓不休
What Makes Good Science? • Important and significant • Original and innovative • Solid and rigorous • Unique and unusual Novelty is essential 语不惊人誓不休
The evaluation process Editorial staff a rejected before in-depth review rejected after in-depth review Board of reviewing editors 口 published( biological a published(physical sci) REJECT 30% 6% REJECT 20% 70% 70%
The evaluation process Editorial staff Board of Reviewing Editors 20-30% REVIEW REJECT REJECT 70% ACCEPT (~10%) rejected before in-depth review rejected after in-depth review published (biological) published (physical sci) 70% 20% 6% 4%